3 folk have voted both DR and Cthulhu ,obviously for each other , Dom has also been quick off the mark ,could he be the traitor ? If he is protecting Cthulhu..........
Either way we will find out they were evil when killed. He isn't putting up much of a fight though is he?
Luckily it's a game really or I might be a bit up in arms about dying! I think I'll stop commenting now because you all have a 50/50 choice. That's the logical choice and the only choice you can actually make without bringing in mostly incorrect conjecture. Make the decision based on this alone and try not to overthink it or post too much conjecture which adds very little to this decision.
Dom isn't the traitor, he is protecting me. We can add that to the list of things we know. I can do that now, the rest of the villagers can go back and add that tomorrow as then youll know for sure. From tomorrow anyone who voted for Daft Row early when inconclusive of how the vote is going can be ruled out as traitor. Beware those hanging on to vote after the decision is basically made. The traitor doesn't necessarily have to vote for me. Ive played that card as traitor before when it looks like the wolf is definitely going to get lynched. He has another to protect. Again check back tomorrow.
Your position Daft Row is then that villagers shouldn't be looking at other subtler clues and should rely on a 50/50 guess. Okay, interesting, Ill leave that for others to interpret.
I had my doubts about cthulhu from Day 1 when he was throwing wild accusations about PJ...those doubts still remain but today's events have somewhat overtaken that and on today's evidence alone I am more inclinded towards Daft Row. As is often the case pick one tonight and if we're wrong pick the other tomorrow.
Sorry to immediately break my self-imposed silence... but yes you are correct however only if they take these factors into account between you and I, no one else! E.g. PJ, CB etc etc
OK so you take a few hours to do some work and it all goes a bit mad All we know is that PJ has silver pants and a role that we believe is good As the messages that say PJ is good also says Optimistic-hornet is good, we have to consider that to be true We can not rely on the messages about HornetGags and CB Realistically its a 50/50 between Daft Row and Cthulhu, one who through around accusations, one who was quiet in the first two days We will all have our theory of which is good and which is evil and we can all probably give a bloody good reason why we think like that. The most important players now are Daft Row and Cthulhu to prove why they are good, tell us why you attacked certain other villagers, who you agreed with and why I think we can only make a decision on what they say and what they can prove
I'm not the traitor, I believe the first message was from the seer. It made references to past messages and had an element of theatrics to it like the first message on day one. Coupled with Daft Row's shadiness and actions yesterday its looking likely that he is evil.
Not sure I have accused anyone outright (Apart from Daft Row who is evil) happy to defend anything I've said if someone posts what it was!
Day 1 I voted for inactive player, nothing to go on. Day 2 I voted for person who voted for me, didn't like that. Nothing to go on. Day 3... sure you all understand why! We've had nothing to go on until now, everything else is conjecture and I won't force myself to believe one way or another without proof. Make your decision based on a logical 50/50 flip of a coin and your gut between Cthulhu and I. And make sure if I go he definately goes tomorrow!
Daft Row could be the Tinker, but if so good to get that out of the way. The way he is playing today is Wolf 101 in terms of cognitive dissonance.
Lol typically yeah, but Thursday nights I have all three kids and somehow it seems three times the handful of the two I have the rest of the week! I've speed read the events of today again and I am wavering..the evidence isn't as strong against Daft Row as I initially thought. I will be voting inside the hour once the kids are showered and in bed but cthulhu probably will get it. I have miked under suspicion from yesterday but I can't remember why right now and don't have time now to look back...one of CT or DR tonight, the other tomorrow if we get it wrong then I will revisit my other suspicions (including those who let squibba go so cheaply).
That makes no sense whatsoever! If you're lynched and found evil then surely it makes sense to protect me as much as any other? Stop trying to confuse wolf.
Yeah I just reread and deleted the second line. Youre right on this. If lynched they will see I am good so wont even think of protecting you. My mistake.
You cant get away from the fundamental point though Daft. Im excited. Team good have got an evil early be you tinker or wolf youre gone in the next two days. Your losing.
Very true. From villagers-who-aren't-me-perspective the wolf could well pick another bad character an implicate them by mistake. Its more likely they are being good statistically. But that option is still there. Whoever is left from tonight isn't proven good (in the eyes of the village) all we know about them is that the wolf has picked them.
We don't usually have a martyr or witness and I think we have been told only 1 special character (PJ)
Could they both be good as well? If one is falsely named by the wolf and the other is the tinker? Aaaaaaarrrrrrghhhhhhhh, this game is confusing.
Maybe the Wolf saw the first message and panicked implicated someone else to take the heat off of them?
It makes the game impossible when you don't know a) how many roles there are; and b) what those exact roles are. There is no way of working anything out because there could always be something no-one has thought of. It all comes down to luck.
Just got back from a meeting and all hell has broken loose, I find it strange that Squibba chose DaftRow (which I followed) and Squibba ends up lynched by a flaky accusation; could Squibba have been the witness?
