Not if we follow the logic of Me and Opti being Good, as it's then true that neither have been viewed. Am I missing something obvious?
Fair enough - I respect that, if it isn't a wolfy trick. But if you are good, you should fight to stay in. Otherwise the wolf might get an extra avoidable victim.
As me and Opti have been viewed thus far, until today where Daft Row was viewed. Process of elimination.
Like you say there isnt too much more to discuss with the evidence we have . Its a binary choice that will then reveal whos message belonged to the Wolf today. Hopefully we will get the evil first time. Unless PJ (or anyone else) can convince me why Day 3 Message 1 is The Seer , Im going to vote Cthulu.
Fine with me as Im on team good you are basically protecting an evil though BRLR and you were on my radar from day one. I suspect Traitor.
Notice how the Messaging style has changed. No more pleasantry start and exclamation mark at the end. And those were from the Wolf. The wolf has changed his writing style to make it less distinctive.
Speculative assumption. Day2 message 2 and Day 3 message 2 are by the same person as they both comment on the wolfs tactic. If this and my previous assumptions are true this woudl imply that these messages are from the seer who is truthfully commenting on the wolfs behaviour. This would mean that The Seer is saying Cthulu is evil and The Wolf is saying Daft row is evil. Goes against this though BRLR which is confusing? Hmmm maybe you are not. Id still like you viewed tomorrow.
Hmm defensive. If I was traitor then so is Steve Leo Beleck as we came to the same assumption following the same logic, posted seperately. But there is only 1 traitor.
Ill take it back actually BRLR. In your position it could be construed as 50:50. I suspect others will vote for me your the first
Yeah I was looking at that too. But both messages are changing style regularly. The Seer really needs to be more consistent to help us identify their message. We shouldn't still be trying to decipher which one is them.
Before today and last night's lynching I suspected Squibba and Cthulhu, was totally wrong with Squibba ! At that stage without much to go on ,I was looking at post timings and content of what was said . So if we assume day 1 message 1 and day 2 message 2 was from the seer we then does that help us figure which is which today, as far as I can see either message could be the wolf . If we can suss this , then we don't have to sacrifice another good player .
Im still weighing up the options Cthulu as it would pain me to send an innocent man to the hanging tree.
For me today is close to 50:50, even though we know the origin of all the messages on Days 1 and 2. The only stylistic clue I can see is: Day 2 Message 2 capitalised GOOD and Day 3 Message 2 capitalised EVIL. They are the only messages to do this and we know that Day 2 Message 2 was from the Seer. So either the Seer has continued consistently capitalising after the first day's poem, or the Wolf has decided to copy their style from yesterday, just as the Seer deserted it. My hunch would be that it's the Seer continuing to capitalise and therefore the Seer is message 2 today. It just seems more likely that the Seer would continue in the same style rather than him abandoning it and the Wolf picking it up at the same time.
If I say who it is they become a target unfortunately. If it begins to go sour for them I'll say but to protect them I'll refrain.
I'm voting Daft Row, he played his part in Squibba being lynched and is oddly rather calm about being lynched. Not exactly the signs of an innocent person.
I do like the new role. Adds a little knowledge. This game has developed quite quickly and we will get a wolf fairly early as well. I just wonder if he is alpha or beta
Is the traitor seen as evil as well? If so, whoever is evil out of the two could just be the traitor, right? Either way it'll be good to get one evil out of the game.
