Summerwolf - Chapter 4 'tabula Rasa'

An early message would be nice.

 

Sorry I forget about you, but yes you're in the same situation as Harrow, we suspect that you are good, but just need some clarification from the seer, really by the getting a lynching, that you are both 100% good.

I think we are all confident that the pirate messages have been from the seer, but as yet they haven't hit an evil player that we can lynch. If we can do that then all of a sudden we have 3 confirmed good players

 

Hang on, you're pushing the Seer in wasting another days viewing? Why would you do that?

 

It was mainly down to the way he was playing dumb in a lot of posts, asking questions that we already all knew the answer to. It seemed like he was trying to sew doubt and confusion.

It's like the 3 or 4 wolves thing from Warehouse - We all know there are only 3, so why even type out the possibility that there could be 4? It's just an attempt to participate in the game, not contribute anything of value to Team Good and to add confusion as people pick up on titbits of information that are false.

TBH so far it's what made me suspect both Dom and Sinatra, however, both of them were good, so it's simply that they were useless to the good side with their posting, rather than evil.

 

am i ?
I am suggesting that if the seer manages to view and evil and get a lynching, then that would prove Harrow and Burnsy to be 100% good

That is of course that as we all suspect, 99%?, the pirate messages are from the seer.

At the moment the naming of Cassetti's beard in one of the messages as evil, later lynched but good, is the only thing that is really tilting the pirate message to be from the seer.

 

Indeed. Cthulhu, Harrow and Burnsy all very, very likely to be good if my calculations are correct.

That means there are 3 wolves amongst the rest. Possibly a traitor too, but we can't confirm that and also, since 2 wolves know each other now, they might well be displaying traitor type behaviour anyway.

 

It genuinely wasn't my intention to cause any confusion, so apologies. I misread the post.

 

If what I think about the Seer is correct, then they will be making good choices so I'm confident of a decent viewing today. Just hope it's soon.

 

To be fair, I'm still interested in WatfordTalk. He's playing a very below the radar game and was named in a post which we suspect is from the Wolf (the same message sender which claimed someone was Evil who turned out to be Good).

Now, since two wolves know each other, there's a chance that the Alpha named a random player, named himself in a show of arrogance or named a player who just happens to be the wolf they don't know the identity of.

Until the messages say otherwuse, I'd say percentage wise, WT is my main suspect at this point.

 

So there's a few of us throwing out our thoughts and a lot of us not saying a d*mn thing.

This is where you'll be finding your 3 wolves based on the last 4 days IMO:

wfcwarehouse
TomWatfordFC
tonycotonstache
Watford Talk
Ashdon
With A Smile
SkylaRose

 

My 3 biggest suspects are in there as well

A message would be really handy right now

 

I mean - no one has discounted you either?

I'd be interested to hear why you've left Moog, EB and Miked off your list when they aren't confirmed good?

 

I'd like to hear a bit more from WT, and Skyla's posting style has changed today which is a little curious and worth nothing even if it's all part of her gameplan. I'm still leaning towards Ashdon/Tony as my prime suspects for now.

I'm pretty sure that along with myself, Burnsy, Moog and Diamond are good for sure. I haven't made my mind up on WAS yet.

A message would be helpful.

 

Noting - not nothing!

 

Of course, nobody knows my status for sure except me, but to be so vocal in this game usually sees yourself dead, so it would be suicide if I was an evil player. The 3 you've mentioned could easily be evil as well but have been putting in the work to root out the dodgy players which evil won't be doing.

 

Strange posts days 1-3 Skyla, and now a couple of rousing speeches. Any thoughts on who is a wolf and why? You're coming across very suspicious to me and it's been noted by others, so you may want to speak out here.

 

Well, they would be doing it if they are selling us up the garden path - and we have already made errors lynching good players.

Think we need to be more measured personally. Moog is an experienced player for example - certainly not beyond him to be seen to be helping whilst doing the opposite.

I’m not saying I doubt him - I’m saying I’m dubious of discounting him. He’s already plumped for Dom and thrown shade at Sinatra who were both good. So could easily be argued he’s not helping - just trying to look like he is. From my experience of watching and/or playing this game, Moog has always been very good at it.

I think anyone who hasn’t been named good by the now obvious seer messages should remain on the table of doubt personally.

Let’s see some messages and work from there - throwing out suspects this early seems silly to me and could lead to another poor lynching choice.

 

With no messages it at least keeps the game interesting, and that's 90% of my reasons for posting.

 

I mean if there were still some role that throws us off scent your messages surely do that. Have you deliberately used 'claw' in your message above?

I'm almost tempted to vote right now!

But I'll wait for our messages of course.

 

From someone who has read your posts over the forum over the years, these posts are nowhere near your usual style.

You’re inexperienced at this game - but you’re firmly on the list of suspects for me. It’s in everyone’s self-interest to declare themselves good and behave as such - but the phrasing of your messages doesn’t even come close to doing that for yourself.

I want to see messages today - but my initial hunch is that your inexperience is outing you.

 

I think you've just put a target firmly on your back.

 

Ashton I have been suspicious of since day 1 when they said that they were a little rusty. Even if you haven’t played for a while, you still know the basics of making mistakes. Although active, they haven’t exactly been finger pointing.

On day 2 and 3 they also went for a pretty safe vote, both that had no influence on who was going to be lynched.

Tony – we know the mistake he made

Tom – Votes very late each time, day 2 and 3 the last vote after someone had already been lynched.
He also dips in and out and like Ashton doesn’t to much finger pointing or trys to ruffle feathers, stir someone up. His very much sitting on the fence.

 

Also, I voted incorrectly for Dom on Friday.
Before that I had put up a tally for who had been voted for to that point.

Your reply to me was that having a tie was the worst thing that could happen. Perhaps this was your way of steering me away from a wolf looking Tonycotonstache and towards the innocent Dom…

 

First Message

I have some awful news to share with the village. Our seer was killed this weekend.
I’m your backup seer.
I was shocked to see that the previous seer viewed Cthulhu as GOOD, Cassetti’s Beard as EVIL, WatfordTalk as GOOD.
I viewed Moog, who is GOOD.
I hope to be more helpful tomorrow morning - 5657

 

I'd add EBHornet to that, though it doesn't help us any.

Yes I did accuse two good players, one of whom was lynched, but I've given my reasons for that.
Accusing Sinatra did no harm as we never had to make a decision one way or the other on him as the Wolf decided that matter for us.

 

Yeah. That's a wolf message.

Also, I'm not top of anyone's list of suspects really (though not off anyone's either) so why would the seer select me to view out of all those available?

I've just been named by the wolf to set me up as a target.