I was thinking that HH might be the seer early on in the game (I thought she might be a wolf but people on here kept referring to the wolf as he), but then she voted against me when Moog and I were pretty close. She might have waited to vote until it was all over however, I cannot remember exactly. I might have a look to see if she has gone with the eventual winner every time actually... The first seer (I haven't read this board to find out who it was, but I'm guessing it was Ashton?) was very good.
It doesn't pay to be noisy in this game, I'm giving you all advance warning I'm going to quiet in the next game. Having said that I came under suspicion for being too quiet very early in this game and was lynched despite being viewed as good :dismay: So I can't win anyway can I :doom:
Sorry mate, not your fault I know, but there has been too many sitting back and not competing in this game, we really should bring in some sort of minimum quota of posts per day for the next game, what do you think?
Evening chaps. What a bunch of idiots team good are! I have no idea what they are thinking. Anyway, my current predictions: Seer: Philippine. Wolf: WAS or steve harrow.
Whenever people don't participate in a game, they get an hour to explain themselves, and if they don't they get killed. If they do though they aren't allowed to do it again, else they'll be killed straight away. Daft Row was killed for inactivity and Abso might well not make it through the night. I could have taken a no tolerance approach but that would have seen nornironhorn gone on day one, moog gone, Abso gone, maybe some others - I can't remember. Oh yeah WatfordTalk as well. Maybe even nairobi horn too. But some have genuine excuses and have added to the game a lot since the day that they would have been killed if I went for a no tolerance strategy. Both ways work in my opinion. People can't always be as active as everyone else, and it's an important part of the game. Quiet tactics are big in this game, and as long as you post once or twice there's no reason you should be penalised. If you don't post or don't vote, you should get your final warning in my opinion. And that's what I've done. And if I'm to be criticised for that, so be it. That's just the way I thought best.
I was really active this game due to work being so dull. It's a shame really, but if it wasn't for my blabbering I doubt we would have got moog.
Players look for clues and find loads, unfortunately they are almost always wrong. Hence my killing cthulhu. I also convinced myself Jellyman was the traitor. If players stuck to the messages and didn't double guess everyone else then good would win so many more games.
Thing is I can see it next game. Day 1 - Vote Cude - he's always evil. Or..... The Seer will do the exact same as this game "View Cude" and i'll be the bloody tinker!
The remaining players: Squibba sonofben HeppyHornet24 merchandiseman41 nairobi hornet wfcmatt Optimistichornet WatfordTalk Cassetti's Beard With A Smile nornironhorn PhilippineOrn steve harrow Abso As I was a mason, I know who the others are and 352 said he won't convert anyone who's not a standard villager, my take on the remaining: Spoiler Squibba - low poster HIGH chance of being a wolf sonofben - mason NOT A WOLF HeppyHornet24 - playing quite conservatively, I don't suspect merchandiseman41 - went missingfor a few days, high up on my suspicions nairobi hornet - genuine reason for absence, UNLIKELY wolf wfcmatt - very quiet HIGH chance Optimistichornet - very quiet HIGH chance WatfordTalk - very quiet HIGH chance Cassetti's Beard - mason NOT A WOLF With A Smile - UNLIKELY wolf nornironhorn - mason NOT A WOLF PhilippineOrn - certainly good, I'm not suspicious steve harrow - very quiet HIGH chance Abso - very quiet but 352 is annoyed, if he was the wolf 352 would've cut some slack. My main suspicions fall on Squibba, wfcmatt, Optimistichornet, WatfordTalk and steve harrow. ... and that's without the complication of a new wolf getting introduced.
Two big players for good taken out last night, I fear for the good team! Good managed a last ditch win last time if I remember correctly, it might have to come down to that again if they can win at all. As "Evil" is looming large over the village.
With you and miked being found good, it blows the whole norwincii code theory out of the water. People saw Norway had accused three people and then decided to make the evidence fit the theory. Luckily for them, one out of three was right. I'm not quite at Cudes level, but I will always be accused of being a wolf in week one, every game. It means that when I am an actual wolf, I've got no chance of seeing a second week, so I just have to go on an aristeia of murders and then kill myself, Ajax style.
It just seems that every time somebody votes for WAS, or begins to interrogate him, they get killed overnight. The way he's been acting too. Constantly saying "if I survive the night" and "I doubt I will get through the night alive". Even if I'm wrong and he's good, he was one of the main protagonists in good being in such a bad position right now. Great game though. If it isn't WAS, the wolf is playing a blinder and now he has some help too,
Happy to be here if I'm honest. I agree if WAS wasn't the last wolf then whoever it was (if they have been playing) has done a good job. I'm still certain it is him though. Think the Guardian has been pretty poor with some of his choices...WAS (obviously) and Merchandiseman two obvious examples.
Any early bids on the new wolf? I think it could be steve harrow, since it was the new wolf that killed me and he seems to have taken some things I've said personally.
I think Steve Harrow could be the original wolf. He voted for abso on his own, taking him away from the group that voted for me who will obviously be under suspicion more than anybody else. He also voted for himself at one stage.
I've got a list of 5 possibles, the seer today would do well to look at posting stats and choose that way as there are no other obvious choices based on what happened since the beginning. I'd be looking at either Asbo, Optimistic or steve harrow to start with.
Was about to post the same thing. Not only are half the people left rarely posting (not against the rules just less exciting), they also have no clue about anything lol.
Just wanted to say something about the non participating players away from the main area so as not to influence any players. As the game loses players then it's natural for some to be quieter for longer periods, it's just how it goes. However, some players have been completely silent for 6 days now which IMO is taking the p*ss. It needs something setup next game to stop this like a minimum daily post number or average daily number.
2nd message today, do I spot a clue. When message says "sort of new", are we looking at the initials...s.o.n.?? sonofben?
