Reading through day 1, 2 and 3 right now. Will post some thoughts soon! Just read through day one, thanks to Moog for taking down Wolfy number 1 with him, assuming Alpha? Onto day two.
This is stupid. Quoted just a bunch of statements stating the obvious clarifying the situation first thing in the morning. Talk about clutching at straws. I've been here but not really posting much as there's nothing for me to add - unless you prefer me posting "I'm confused" every hour just to satisfy your post quota...
Weird to point out something like that. Trying to deflect something or put a cat amongst the pigeons?
Oh come on guys, you don't think that 6 or 7 posts between you in three days, 2 of you not voting on day 1 and you all confirming that the wolves know each other are all slightly suspicious behaviours ?
Right now that cassettis beard is here no one ought to vote for him. He will be in the game no matter what tomorrow. Now we are left with the choice of SLB or someone else.
I had a good look at the last couple of days, none of these guys' postings sticks out much, I think nisman is a victim of his own schedule. However one person's performance overall sticks out a bit and was suggested by Squibba yesterday, is NW Orn. My suspicions are firmly on him now.
Stating the obvious = suspicious. Remember that people. Chucking vague accusations at around 6 people with nothing to back it up is going the right way for a lynching.
Bizarrely you were also trying to lead and influence where people vote on day 1, yet being relatively inactive, was the reason I voted for you. In the last game I voted for mike for the exact same reason and as it turned out Mike was the Alpha. Mike also voted for you on day 1, after I did, so I would take a fair guess that he knew the reason why I voted as I did. ( I can't be 100% sure this is why Mike voted for Grrwood ) At the moment its all gut feel, my gut instinct says you are all very quiet, have missed voting and put the same sort of comments in regarding watching, keeping an eye out, etc
OK you're actually being stupid now. I've said my reasons for basically being awol on the first two days. They were real life reasons that I decided to share into the game. I understand why you're being suspicious, but what I've said on the two previous days are 100% true. Hence why I'm more active now because my exams are over
I'm not questioning your reasons and have no reason to think that it was anything but the truth.... As for being more active - you've replied to me twice and made 1 other post
Lead people?! Like you said, I missed the vote! And I'd rather lynch an inactive the first night so people who actually want to play don't miss out at the expense of someone who's forgotten.
Otter why does why performance stick out above anyone else's ? I've been very busy at work all week as we've had the accountants in auditing and every time I have a minute to read up on what's happened I have to go through pages of theory and conflicting theory. I don't see the point in just re-hashing other peoples points as it just clutters the thread and inevitably by the time I've read everything things have moved on. For what it's worth I think SLB is probably the Harlot but is certainly not confirmed as good. The debate about how effective his powers as an outed Harlot are rages on.
Early vote for me from Otter for no good reason. Trying to deflect attention from something ? All very suspicious
Now that CB has been unfortunately outed as good it may make sense for Guardian to protect him tonight ?
A strong enough opinion to vote early so can you elaborate/highlight your reasoning to convince a following?
I've been through all 3 days, there is very little to go on other than instinct that SLB (see my post from earlier), you were suggested by Squibba yesterday but I only noticed it after you were in my sights, you have voted very late on both days when the result had already been settled. TBF it was between you and Pozzman.
My own thoughts are Chtulthu is evil. 1. Only followed others voting. Always goes for the popular opinion once it's almost done. Just said would vote slb but couldnt find the day vote. It's right there fella. 2. Never really gives an opinion. Casually agrees with others but mainly just follows. 3. Convenietly unavailable at key times. Like now.
I know I voted for SLB yesterday based on my initial thoughts that I felt that the second message was the seers. My earlier post highlighting why it's extremely unlikely to be SLB, I can't bring myself to vote for someone who I almost certain is innocent. My reasons for NW Orn maybe vague but I explained them in my last post. If I were evil I wouldn't be playing like this now so I'm not trying to coerce anyone else to vote for NW Orn.
Like you I thought about Cthulhu, but he voted early enough on both days to make a difference. I've narrowed down evil to 3 of 8 so IMO there is a good chance that NW Orn is evil.
Not sure my voting pattern points to anything really. Day 1 the consensus was to vote off the inactive (until late) Ybot. Yesterday I was called away at short notice to my daughter's school and by the time I got back everything had been decided. If voting late (for good reasons) and with the majority puts me in your sights then many others must be in there too.
Just by saying you're not trying to coerce voting is doing exactly that. Lets stick to facts rather than speculation.
People seem to be really clutching at straws here , naming others for no apparent reason . Nothing wrong with intuition but it needs to be tempered and cross referenced with logic .
Just checking in but nothing seems to have moved on . At the moment I'm voting SLB even though I think he's more likely good than evil , which pains me but I can't see any alternatives . Voting for anyone else would be pure speculation on my behalf . Am totally open to being persuaded that there is a better option than SLB although I'm not convinced by Otters picking NW Orn unless he explains his logic .
Can guarantee you I'm a villager, I'm finding it harder than anticipated to make sense of things without people shouting randomly like yesterday, that's all.
We don't seem to be any further on from yesterday to be honest, with only SLB named as evil still in the game (although I do believe he is the harlot). Opti and Squibba both named as good today - could be random choices, could be wolves protecting themselves, it's all just speculation. I'm unhappy with various members pushing lynchings based on nothing but gut instincts (Otter and With A Smile), there is no point chucking about hysterical accusations. Saying that, I'm still unsure how to vote tonight.
BRLR a vote for SLB is at this point a vote wasted. 1. We know there is a harlot. 2. SLB claims to be the harlot. 3. No other player has claimed to be the harlot. 4. The only way therefore that SLB could not be the harlot is if one of the other good players killed before SLB made the claim was the harlot. That leaves Ybot, as all the others have died in their own homes. I just cant see it. We are better off making a concerted effort about a villager via shifty behaviour than voting off one whom is almost certainly good.
As am I, I'm seeing rather little to go on. However I'm sure that SLB is the harlot having gone back through the last two days.
SLB can you reveal who you have been spending the nights with as that would help rule out some more players?
If anything is wrong here correct me. So we have a few confirmed Good now (If we believe SLB to be the Harlot which is increasingly likely so): SLB Cassetti's Beard <One only known by SLB> Moog (Dead) Mike (Dead) Ashdon (Dead) Diamond (Dead) We still aren't sure of today's messages being from the Seer between: Squibba OptimisticHornet SLB, Technically. Very, very likely to be Good. Those NOT Seer'd are: Powerjugs BRLR Otter The Pozzman Grrwood With a Smile Cassetti's Beard Meh! Cthulhu Hornetsgags Nisman Domthehornet NW Hornet HH24 This is what we know for certain. Everything else is up for debate.
Actually powerjugs I ought to be on the bottom list too, as the wolf could well have claimed me to be good. I need to vote by 5:30 as off to spinning, so I need to have a think. I will not be voting for SLB, squibba or myself at this point.
