It's why I put you in the unsure list with Squibba and SLB. SLB's there as even though he was named Evil we all seem to agree he's not and his actions are consistent. Fixed. Cheers.
Right, here's what I know based on today... So in conclusion... Joking apart all the posts have been blind stabs in the dark and tempers are starting to fray. So if we look at Day 2 message 1 - that must be the wolf - claimed Daft Row was evil when we now know he was good and repeated that Ashdown was good, which we already knew. Day 2 message 2 - logic suggests that must be the seer, in which he claimed SLB was evil. Right?
we've already outed good players in CB let's not do it again . That just makes it easy for the wolves no ? Or am I missing something here . The Harlot could be keeping quiet to maintain their powers .
This ^^^^ Ok if SLB is the harlot then that's a wasted vote tonight although he has been named evil but maybe by the wolf. I'm beginning to agree with Meh in the absence of anything else.
Just catching up. I believe SLB is the harlot as all dead players have been named as "good" rather than "quite good" & there is no good reason for the harlot not to have come forward by this point. I am inclined to think both Squibba and Opti are good; one has been viewed as such by the Seer, one named as such by the wolf - the wolves know one another & the Alpha wouldn't want to put the other wolf in the spotlight. So I don't think there's any point voting for any of them. Likewise, if you believe SLB you must believe CB when he says he's good. So that's 4 players "off radar" for now. I know I'm good so that's 5. Sadly, this does mean taking a slight punt on voting and I have to do so soon as leaving to take daughter to school for play imminently. BRLR, DomtheHornet and Chuthlhu all in the frame for me. Apologies to all if wrong.
He's already ruled out revealing that player to protect them. He said CB was Good as momentum was starting to swing against them.
A Harlot is only called Good. That was what happened to me at the end of the last game. There is still a small chance that one of the early killed players were the Harlot, but realistically it would have had to have been ycoom... ycom... Him.
Will do. Was going by end of game write up last game. Read it. You're correct. Editing table. Fixed table. Congratulations, you're now unbanished.
Wrong. For a start both messages on Day 2 repeated that Ashdown was good, so that doesn't help at all. Daft Row was the Tinker, that's why the Seer viewed them as Evil, even though they were Good. The Wolf then responded by naming me as Evil.
I don't particularly suspect Dom, however do find it perculiar how assertive Cthulhu is about SLB and "the odds" considering yesterday he was saying
Ok ive got to go, I'm voting Cthulhu. Think he is playing a clever game to be honest. Sorry if I'm wrong Cthulhu but it comes down to just a small group.
No, the Seer will view them as Evil but the unfortunate sod won't know they are a Tinker, and when they are lynched they are called out as Good.
Did you not read my post from earlier? Summer Werewolf II - Day 3 Post #56 I don't think that there is a logical way that SLB is a wolf unless he's Alpha and got cojones the size of Deeney's pay packet.
It could be one of the biggest bluffs in Werewolf history but with the information we have it's simply impossible to be, so far.
A tinker is a good character. The tinker is told they are a 'simple villager' which effectively they are. However, if the tinker is viewed by the seer, the seer is told they are evil. That's it.
Yesterday, when the Seer named Daft Row as Evil, the only person who would have known that was definitely wrong would have been the Traitor as they knew the identity of both wolves and the Traitor (themself). The Seer would have thought the odds were that Daft Row was genuinely Evil but could have been the Tinker, the Alpha would have been unlikely to know for definite after only one day so then had to name a random to protect who they thought was the Wolf. So yesterday, the Traitor must have been laughing themselves silly knowing that the whole day's discussion was a red herring. They didn't have to push the discussion in any particular direction as they knew a Good would get lynched. BUT... after Daft Row was lynched, they would have a vested interest in pushing everyone towards lynching me next. Cthulhu immediately suggested I should be targeted next in yesterday's voting thread after the result was known. Then a flurry of early messages this morning - the first one saying that Message 1 was a Wolf message with no explanation, then various other messages trying to influence the voting to get me. I think he's the Traitor.
I'm still not convinced by Grrrwood and Dom. Both have been very quiet and the messages about knowing wolves and keeping their eyes on someone. Sorry Grrwood, I had the gut feeling on Day 1 and am going to go with it again I have a strange feeling that i'll be seeing some of you in the graveyard or in next game - l8rs
I would've made more posts unrelated to this but straight away I'm having to defend myself because of a baseless accusation. Surely that's obvious to you? Anyways that's enough of this. Regardless of what you believe of me, we need tovote wisely to get rid of the remaining wolves
It came down to: NW Orn; DomtheHornet; BRLR; Grrwood and Cthutlhu for me & I changed my mind several times before going for the latter (can't be bothered to try to spell it again). Sorry if wrong, C, but it seems to me you're playing a similar game to that which you played when you were the alpha to my beta.
So me Dom and CTH are the 2 wolves and the traitor ? There s been some clutching at straws this afternoon but I think that wins the award .
I'm voting SLB. Sorry SLB , I know you are likely good but it's all I have to go on . Voting for anyone else is pure speculation . I kinda hope you survive as it seems the vote is going to be spread wide .
BRLR - can you explain why you tried to mislead everyone this morning by saying that the Seer might be swapping styles when we know full well that message was from the Wolf? Third time I've asked you now. Your play is baffling me more than anyone. I really can't tell if you're Team Evil or a well-meaning blunderer!
I'm not playing a very clever game am I? Throwing accusations around like the last game when, like now, I am a simple villager. SLB is evil if like last game you lynch me and daft you'll probably have made exactly the same mistake. Those who don't learn from history are prone to repeat it. The time I was a wolf I kept quiet and was subtle. But that won't attract attention and votes. I can't believe with no proof the village is going to go this way again? That's all I'm going to say. Lynch me when I'm pointing out the obvious and it'll be the same result
