VOTE- Carlisle to Luton- GOOD OR BAD?

Discussion in 'The Transfer List' started by Desmond, Mar 2, 2007.

  1. Desmond

    Desmond Panic Buy Signing

    The people on here seem to be split so....
     
  2. afanof

    afanof First Team

    How about a 'really not bothered' option?
     
  3. Desmond

    Desmond Panic Buy Signing

    There is one...

    Don't vote
     
  4. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    Good. He needs first team football - at least by going to the scum he knows a couple of the players (Spring, Langley) so will settle quickly and they need a centreback so he will play. It's only for a month. He'll be back in April ready to restart his career with us.
     
  5. brumhorn

    brumhorn First Year Pro

    good - for reasons stated in the main thread
     
  6. afanof

    afanof First Team

    I have a vote, I wish to use it to express my view. Your poll options are loaded, therefore carp.

    Consider my ballot paper SPOILED
     
  7. jobr

    jobr Squad Player

    Bad IMHO.

    The guy needs a loan move without doubt, however i would have sent him to a 1001 other clubs before considering the Scum or Qphahaha.

    Clarke is very friendly with Springey and his family outside of the game so that may have been a factor also in the decision.
     
  8. jobr

    jobr Squad Player

    :eek: :eek: :eek: :eek:
     
  9. Chewitt

    Chewitt Forum Extraordinaire

    Should have been a not bothered option, however without one i have to say good.
     
  10. The Voice of Reason

    The Voice of Reason First Team Captain

    Luton not ideal choice.............

    but what the hell, as long as he gets some games under his belt and hopefully comes back fit and ready to go, I don't really care who he plays for :sign12:
     
  11. Berkohorn

    Berkohorn Reservist

    "Carlisle to Luton" - bloody long journey, nearly as bad as Watford to Plymouth - caravan anyone?

    :)
     
  12. coll123

    coll123 Reservist

    are watford loseing it we sell one of are players to them and now we give are center back to them on loan we are ment to hate them not fecking help them out its a joke i would rather him go and help leeds stay up than scum town shocking move
     
  13. Chewitt

    Chewitt Forum Extraordinaire

    Coll, the fans are meant to hate them, WFC as a football club don't have a rivalry just the fans. As hartvix said in another thread, there's no such thing as rival clubs, just rival fans.
     
  14. PaddingtonsYellowArmy

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy First Team Captain

    and rival bookies :)

    CC will of course then become a hero amongst the masses of s.c.u.m haters when he scores 3 own goals and causes their demise to fizzy lge 1.
     
  15. coll123

    coll123 Reservist

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy i hope your right mate i would hate to think a watford player will help them stay up
     
  16. PaddingtonsYellowArmy

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy First Team Captain

    Howver there are many wfc fans who saying going down doesn't bother them because they want to play looshyte next season.

    What i do feel would be bad, either way if looshyte stay up or go down, is that CC doesn't get booed etc by sections of our fans when he does come back.
     
  17. removed

    removed Guest

    Its a shame some of are fans are, as soft as those who let him go to luton.
     
  18. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    I would be extremely interested to know how many people have decided the move is a bad thing solely on the basis that it's Luton, rather than say, the best thing for the player.
     
  19. removed

    removed Guest

    He could of gone to a number of other clubs. Im sure there are a few london teams who would have had him.
     
  20. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    Based on what?
     
  21. removed

    removed Guest

    Carlisle when fit would be a great player to any championship or league one team.
     
  22. PaddingtonsYellowArmy

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy First Team Captain

    So he'll be in out first team next season and people can't complain because he is a good championship player.
     
  23. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    I say again, on what basis are you saying that there were other London area clubs interested in him? Luton were obviously the only viable local club.
     
  24. PaddingtonsYellowArmy

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy First Team Captain

    i know you are PC correct, but thats an extreme you are taking it too. Do not spell the name correctly, please.

    Or maybe in french - Le Bog FC.
     
  25. WatfordÉire

    WatfordÉire Squad Player

    lol:]] :]] :]]
     
  26. albangura9

    albangura9 Squad Player

    I agree a loan move is good, but why luton :mad:
     
  27. PaddingtonsYellowArmy

    PaddingtonsYellowArmy First Team Captain

    I know the answer to that one Bang bang..

    Because all the pubs in lootown (le bog fc) a normal person wouldn't be seen dead in any of them.

    Its a rehab month:)

    Disclaimer - purely for humour Clarke.
     
  28. lm_wfc

    lm_wfc First Team

    good, so what if he does help luton, the best rivalrys are always the close ones, -why else are man u bigger rivals with liverpoool than man city?

    in fact when we are established in the top 10 i would even wan them to come up, (but not happily) - nad with less points than we did. as long as they arent better than us.
     
  29. The Voice of Reason

    The Voice of Reason First Team Captain

    Wrong

    Not according to Aidy's article on the club site :rolleye1:

    Other clubs showed an intrest, but only Luton made a firm bid ;)

    So aidy shipped him out to get him match fit asap :angel3:
     
  30. Budfrog

    Budfrog Reservist

    Excellent Move .... Come On You Hatters !!!!!
     
  31. carlbwfc

    carlbwfc Academy Graduate

    Gerrup Sons

    how DO! i think people studyin at tod uni shouldnt have time to post messages on tod forums! And i also think that danielb136 is a right loser that needs to get a grip. Gotta go now need to get the sausage out ma DVD player . See Thee later
     
  32. watford_pyro

    watford_pyro Squad Player

    good as he needs the match fitness its luton thats crap but if they were the only team who came in with a firm offer for him then thats the way the cokie crumbles
     
  33. ryan_wfc

    ryan_wfc Reservist

    he is SCUM will never clap him again if he ever puts a watford shirt back on

    i would be pleased if he did;nt
     
  34. hornmeister

    hornmeister Tired

    Good move. It's local, as pointed out he has friends there and he will be able to show his passion for the game. Gives him a chance to get to match fitness without risking our results.

    He could of course be another agent on a mission to bring them down.
     
  35. afanof

    afanof First Team

    I would imagine that ALL of the people who have said it's a bad thing have done so on the basis that it's Luton and not because they think Carlisle would benefit more from a month in our reserves.:rolleyes:
     

Share This Page