Something To Think About

Discussion in 'The Transfer List' started by Birdydoug, Apr 5, 2007.

  1. Birdydoug

    Birdydoug The Flying Scotsman

    Manchester United will allow Ben Foster to go on loan again if he has not displaced Edwin van der Sar by Christmas. (Daily Express)

    I wonder where
    Ok paper talk, but where would he go ?
     
  2. Birdydoug

    Birdydoug The Flying Scotsman

    Only way he will displace VDS is if he is injured
     
  3. jobr

    jobr Squad Player

    A premiership club not a mid table championship one for sure.
     
  4. Oliver Philips MBE

    Oliver Philips MBE Academy Graduate

    Sunderland, on the proviso they go up!
     
  5. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    I think we'll see Foster and VDS being rotated, with them sharing a 50/50 split of games next season. If not, Oli's Sunderland guess is a good call. Fergie is known to like his up and coming players to play not just regular first team football but also in front of large crowds on a regular basis. I think Sunderland could offer both next year.
     
  6. Aberystwyth_Hornet

    Aberystwyth_Hornet Squad Player

    I doubt he’d come back to us because hopefully Aidy will sign a good replacement so we don’t need to rely on signing Foster in January. Sunderland sounds a likely bet, what is their current goal keeping situation like? The obvious link is Keane being their manager, he must have a good idea on the talent of the other youngsters at Man U as well
     
  7. Timbers

    Timbers Apeman


    yep, can see him going there and joining the rest of Man Utd reserves. Solskaar meant to be going there as well.

    Sunderland do not have great keepers, Darren Ward who was 3rd choice at Norwich and some Hungarian (Fulop) bloke they swapped Ben ALwick with from Spurs. They certainly need a better keeper.
     
  8. Watford_Rule

    Watford_Rule Academy Graduate

    Foster out on Loan again

    Manchester United will allow Ben Foster to go on loan again if he has not displaced Edwin van der Sar by Christmas. (Daily Express)
     
  9. wurzel_sepp

    wurzel_sepp Reservist

    but i think ben will become nr.1. in my eyes he's much better than van der sar
     
  10. Rookery_'Orn!

    Rookery_'Orn! Squad Player

    Sunderland are mad, On SSN it said they're after Diego Forlan And Damien Duff! :]]
     
  11. kingjames77

    kingjames77 Squad Player

    For sure!


    .
     
  12. To pints of Lager now

    To pints of Lager now Squad Player

    Ben will not be back here next season and man utd have already said if he did go on loan then it would be another prem club.
     
  13. Greek God

    Greek God Reservist

    I wonder if he will have lee as number 1 and loach as back up next season and not actually bring in another keeper.
     
  14. hornetmaster

    hornetmaster Reservist

    If Edwin van der Sar`s performance yesterday was typical, Ben will walk into the team.:)
     
  15. Greek God

    Greek God Reservist

    ben will probably be cup keeper next year....
     
  16. luke_golden

    luke_golden Space Cadet

    One gossip column (can't remember which) said we were going to be raiding Man Utd again this summer for Kuczsak on loan next year.
     
  17. Rookery_'Orn!

    Rookery_'Orn! Squad Player

    wouldnt mind him.
     
  18. UEA_Hornet

    UEA_Hornet First Team Captain

    I think he'd be a good signing but exactly that - a signing. I'm sick of this loaning crap now and it benefits WFC very little to continue grooming Man Utd players for the Premiership and England teams. My only concession to loaning would be to do a similar deal as we did with King and take Kuczsak on loan for the season with an option to buy at the end if he impresses.
     
  19. The Voice of Reason

    The Voice of Reason First Team Captain

    Lets face it............

    .................although Ben has only been on loan, he has spent two seasons with us, and that is longer than many of our actual signings over the years, so I don't have a problem with long term loans, of at least a season.

    The only problem is that this season he has been been unavailable to play against his own team, which personally I think is an unfair rule, as it discriminates against other premiership sides, but thats another story. Overall though I would much rather have had him here, all be it on loan, than to have been without him.

    I have to agree that anything shorter than a full seasons capaign is not such a good idea, but a loan of at least a season is almost as good as a permanent signing in my book.
     
  20. lm_wfc

    lm_wfc First Team

    he will replace van der sar next year though, so this is a silly post :)
     
  21. WatfordÉire

    WatfordÉire Squad Player

    what would the options be mate?

    if its decent enough, i'll do it tonight
     

Share This Page