Not entirely sure what is meant by Day 5 Message 1 which states " DR was not trying to save himself". Thoughts ?
My thoughts. It also means that Im likely to be attacked tonight as The Wolf will know for certain that The Seer has called me as GOOD. For mine and all of ours' survival its imperative we lynch PO ...and PJ dont stay with me tonight.
On Thursday he was first to suggest that he and Cthulhu should be lynched, and he said it again near the end of the day. I'm not particularly sure why he did it TBH because he would have known that he was good.
back up seer has had 2 calls lets hope he is right this time just an observation but Mike you seem to be very keen on pushing PO as evil , so what if your on team evil and sowing confusion here , must hand it to the wolves seeing as they are running rings round us !
I guess he knew that it he and Cthulu were going to be lynched anyway so he at least would be vindicated and seemed busy at work so not overly bothered if he died.
Its another DR/CTHU standoff between PO and Meh, but at least this time we know there is no tinker so we will definitely get an evil tonight or tomorrow night. As I said before , only me , The Wolf and The Seer know Im good which makes me side very heavily with Message 1 and that PO is evil. Unless someone can come up with some strong evidence between now and this afternoon, thats where my vote is going. I have to go out for day, but will be dropping by early afternoon to see how its going.
Before I go, this is who is left and a rough idea of how much they ve posted ( from memory rather than analysis). Please correct if wrong PowerJugs - GOOD (HARLOT) Otter - FREQUENT POSTS Meh FREQUENT POSTS NorwayHornet FREQUENT POSTS Miked2006 -FREQUENT POSTS Steve Leo Beleck FREQUENT POSTS BigRossLittleRoss FREQUENT POSTS PhillipineOrn LOW POSTS Hornetgags - LOW POSTS Going on the speculative assumption that infrequent posters are more likely to be WOLFish than those who dont I would speculate that PO and HG are WOLVES and one of the other frequent posters is the traitor bearing in mind the traitors weapon is dissemination of false info, frequent posting would be beneficial to their cause.
Morning All, the bar is open! Wow, I've been named! I can categorically state that I am definitely good, or was given a good role. I can only think that I've been named by the wolf as I was the only one to repeatedly call out that either Cthulthu or Daft Row could have been a tinker so they see me as a possible threat. BRLR is therefore good, as is Powerjugs, and I know I am. That leaves in the spotlight the remaining 5 for me (though I still can't get out of my head that there is possibly another possible tinker and also 1 more special role). Also as an aside, Norway, did you just call Otter out as the seer in your message???
Just realised that Im going to die tonight whatever happens... 1- If we lynch a wolf tonight, there will still be one wolf left, who will go for me. 2- If we dont lynch a wolf tonight then at least one of them will attack me. My only hope of escape is if we dont lynch a wolf and the 2 wolves arent sure which one should attack me and to avoid attacking each other they both stay away. However Id rather we just got a wolf tonight and my death was in a good cause .
If two wolves attack the same person then they both find out each other's identities, that's the only small mercy we've had in this game.
Incorrect. If they both attack the same villager they find out each others identities and both live. It's only if they select the other that the beta dies.
So that means its not a small mercy as Otter says, as surely we dont want the Wolves to know each others identity. EDIT I misunderstood Otter, its been a small mercy that it hasnt already happened. Is that correct Otter ? It also means Im definitely dead tonight, whatever the outcome of today. Meh bring down your finest bottle of single malt, Im going to enjoy my last day .
Meh isn't a frequent poster BRLR coming alive a bit now though, Ok we have 9 players left 3 evil ,let's assume we lynch a good , then wolves make 2 kills that's 6 players 3 evil and 3 good , that's game over right !
Good post. I actually believe you, and I think that you are good. You're part of the reason I believe the first message.
Yes, had the wolves chosen the same, they'd know each other and we'd have one more villager right now but with them not knowing each other there's still an outside chance one of them will choose the other. The best thing we can hope for tonight is that if we lynch PO and he's proven to be the traitor and one of the remaining wolves choose the other then evil will be down to one tomorrow.
What if you are evil, and doing the same? I'm not sowing confusion - I'm doing the complete opposite. I'm not sure whether you're evil or not, but your finger pointing at people not even mentioned in the posts is suspicious. Especially right after PO has been named evil for the second time. We have to stick to the messages, and be logical in thinking about the purpose behind them. Anything else is just random noise and likely to be from the traitor. Sure, the seer can view me tomorrow if PO is good - but I'll be wolf-bait the following evening.
I voted a tad early, but I have to have a short lunch break and then I'm in a meeting until 3ish, I'm starting to think Norway is showing signs of influencing, looking back at conversation history Norway posted most on Thursday when the traitor knew that neither DaftRow nor Cthulhu were evil. Apologies if I'm wrong Norway.
I ve been having similar thoughts about Norway as Traitor but have kept quiet up until now. I suggest the Seer views Norway tonight and we lynch PO. If PO is GOOD ( which I doubt very strongly ) then we lynch Meh as a certain EVIL the next night.
Apology accepted Otter but it's P.O. you should be apologising to Ok here's the deal if we don't score a wolf tonight we are screwed ,if we lose the back up seer and score a wolf (2 out of 3 chance) we are very slightly less screwed So I am outing myself as the back up seer look at my previous posts and find out how many times I have dropped not so subtle hints (see, seer seem etc) I tell you what I know for sure PO is good MEH is evil Good luck team good you will need it , I am suspicious of Mike as another evil player but this is only a gut feeling and not definite. So long it's been fun
I agree with this. Norway, what game are you playing today, now randomly having a go at Miked? Makes no sense. Regarding me pointing out BRLR as good, I'm not signalling his demise, but logically trying to lower the odds of lynching a wolf tonight, what we should all be trying to do. Randomly pointing the finger is causing us all confusion. I'm obviously voting for PO as he is either wolf or traitor (or one of us iis a second tinker!).
Norway, if you were the seer then outing yourself now would be the worst thing to do. It's would be too early as without seer messages for the rest of the game could be disastrous. Therefore I can only assume traitor protecting PhilippineOrn???
Ok, I know you are the traitor now. Desperate last attempt to save POs life as you see the tide turning against him. Outing yourself as back up seer is a suicidal attempt to save PO . If you were the SEER why would you save a good PO only to sacrifice yourself as the Seer which is even worse for Team GOOD. Also Norway said Meh was misleading me by making me assume I am guaranteed dead tonight, but I think it is clear I am guaranteed dead tonight . I feel pretty sure PO is WOLF and Norway is EVIL, most likely the Traitor as he seems to know who is WOLF whereas it seems the 2 WOLVES dont yet know each others identity as we have had 2 attempted kills every night. Lynch PO tonight. Seer views Norway.
Why on earth would the seer throw themselves to the wolves this early in the day, after a single vote? If what you say is true, and PO is good then we lose the seer tonight and we still stand absolutely no chance tomorrow. Either way we lose.
If we're right about PO, I've had a thought. If I stay with a Wolf or Traitor overnight then I die. That's guaranteed. However, if I announce who I stay with, and then it's revealed I died because I stayed in the same place as them then you know that person is evil and either a Traitor or Wolf. If we had one or two more people I'd be comfortable with this but it's very risky in our current situation. If PO is Good, we lose 1. If I announce where I go and they are Good we lose 2 and then a third to a Wolf. We could lose 4 Good players if it's the worse case scenario. Or 2 with a guaranteed Evil kill the next day.
Incorrect Mike think about , we lynch P.O. who is good wolves make 2 kills of which I am one leaves 6 players 3 are evil and 3 are good Team evil wins As the back up seer I have to try to ensure that team good gets to day 6 I left many hints that I was the back up seer over my posts over last 2 days ,unfortunately only person who picked up on it was team evil , as soon as Otter started the ball rolling voting P.O. I had to literally throw myself to the wolves .
It s a clever plan PJ but only as a desperate reaction to having nothing else to go on , as it is high risk. I think we have good evidence PO is WOLF . This has been hugely backed up by Norways clumsy (false) outing of himself as seer whilst combining it with a statement of POs goodness, which further implicates PO.
