Discussion in 'Werewolf: The forum game' started by Otter, Nov 21, 2022.
Village open again.
Firstly. England. Wow.
Secondly. Var. Dear God.
Thirdly. Where did we get to on this????
So Mike is gone, and wasn't the Seer, but some other new role which we will find out about at the end.
We have had one message from the back-up Seer, which whilst truthful about my goodness, is likely to be from evil as the Seer isn't dead.
Genuinely no clue what to think. But we are still expecting a message from the Seer.
Anonymous message #2 (received during the football)
“Good Afternoon Cronies,
The reality is I was never going to out myself on Friday as your Seer, however I feel like my hand may be forced today as this may well be my last viewing.
I have absolutely no idea what happened earlier or the implications for the game from a special role perspective, but I can only lay out what I have done from a viewing perspective to date:
So far, I have viewed the following - and been incredibly unlucky in doing so. I think anyway(!):
Day 1: nornironorn - Good.
Day 2: wfcmoog - Good.
Day 3: tonycotonstache - Good.
Today, I have viewed ‘wfcSinatra’. He is also ‘Good’, for which I can only apologise.
I divulged my code the other day, so anything today will be new and not of use. Look for similarities in my messages, whether that be formatting, font or language if you are seeking to confirm the above checks out.
For what it’s worth though:
Cheers Geoff. 19,063.”
Was Mike some kind of martyr?
Honestly, **** knows what to believe.
Okay, this clears things up more. Second message is the actual Seer. Tony and Sinatra confirmed good. Slow and steady progress. Evil cocked up by posting before we found out Mike wasn't the Seer.
The only thing clear to me is that pretty much every time I think I’ve been logical and correct, something happens to make me believe that I am on the wrong track entirely. But, anyway, because I’m an idiot, I still think the last message is probably the Seer. Which would mean tony and Sinatra are good. I was hoping the Seer would view WAS but hey ho.
In my view:
Likely Good (both protected by Guardian)
With A Smile
I don’t know what mike’s role is but I’m wondering if the wolves, like some of us, thought he might be evil rather than the seer. Maybe he was some kind of martyr role but the wolves, like us, thought he might be the traitor - remember they don’t know the other evil players any more than we do.
So the idea on the number 1 song I suggested might be true?
Unbelievable if so. In this game though anything is at play.
Incidentally, a guardian save means nothing - remember, the guardian knows no more or less than any other player in the game (apart from the traitor, who knows more than any other player)
I would argue it doesn't mean nothing. It requires both the guardian and wolf to think they (the person being attacked/protected) are good.
Not sure what is more confusing. This game or the VAR / Added time combination in Qatar. That game felt like it went on for years.
I guess to me the intriguing one is HappyHornet. Early doors I was convinced moog and his intentions were good, and it felt like HH24 was of a similar mindset. Both ended up ‘trusting’ Mike on Friday and voting to lynch Norn.
I’m with Tom with regards to his breakdown. Only the jury would still be out on him for me as well as HH24 and WAS.
At the moment I am tempted to vote for WAS. I have no clue what’s going on anymore to be perfectly honest and we have no named evil players. I think the last message is the Seer so I think Tony and Sinatra are good. I think WAS may have been hinting to the traitor to give info about good players yesterday. I have zero faith in my logic so im probably completely wrong.
I am also leaning towards WAS.
I think the seer was right not to out themselves on Friday. There were reservations about Mikes role, so if the seer did out themselves, I think it would have left us in a much worse position. The only unfortunate thing is they haven't been lucky enough to find an evil player.
It does mean that we will all be having a random guess tonight.
I’m not sure about you either, mind.
I'm also with this, I just don't know how one splits WAS or HH24?
I'm still wary of the players who were less active in the early stages. It's harder to stay quiet as the game goes on, but important to stay under the radar when there are more players.
Not a massive fan of moaning about referees but just how that can be a pen for Iran and the Maguire bear hug wasn't is genuinely baffling, can't see one reason why they're not the same thing?
If moog was a reverse tinker, one thing I’m confused about is how many evil players are left? Was he also a wolf/traitor and so we only have two evil players left, or was his role an extra evil role and so we still have three evil players left? The answer to this would make a strategic difference to whether or not the seer or guardian should reveal themselves if they come under any threat today.
Like this you mean?
I was thinking more of Tom to be honest
I have my serious doubts currently about
@Otter are we allowed to ask how many evil players are left in the game?
Looking back on day 3 messages.
"Frustrating as though it is, given we have another player named, I feel like the web is closing on Evil. Stay positive."
Quote from Friday's message.
With A Smile?
Any of of these 3 for me personally.
I actually clicked on that, thinking it might be an explanation of the reverse tinker role…
Sorry forgot this had restarted. Took the dog for a wander after the game, the only time it has stopped raining in Somerset today!
But the Seer wouldn’t know who’s evil any more than we do? They only know who they’ve viewed so how can they give clues about who’s evil when they only have certainty about the players they have viewed. They can normally try to sniff out the traitor, as they are more likely to steer players away from the actual seer’s messages. But in this game, with all the extra roles and messages, who knows?
If they had that much of an inkling they would have also viewed those players in the next few days
What time does the village shut tonight?
6:30 or earlier if all 7 votes are in
So from my mind at the moment we have three options:
With A Smile
My concern from Friday is that happy was quite keen for the seer to reveal themselves to help out with the Miked situation. Obviously would have been very beneficial for evil if they had done so.