Discussion in 'Werewolf: The forum game' started by Otter, Nov 17, 2022.
I don't suspect Sinatra in the slightest at the moment.
I'd just like to know their reasons.
Not sure we’ll get the answer. Don’t think Sinatra is online.
One of Messages 2 or 3 is definitely lying as both claim to have viewed Norn yesterday which can't be true and therefore rules out the third character being good. One is also imitating the other's style.
Therefore Message 1 today is highly unlikely to be the Seer. I rest my case.
I thought this viewpoint was one endorsed by most of the village…
Ok. I'm going for chtulthu with an eye on SLB.
Not totally convinced by SLBs day one defense as he wasn't that active all day, then at 4pm sent 3 messages in 25 minutes one of which tagged Harrow. Seemed a bit panicky to me.
Other than that I've not really a clue.
Yer I’m not sure that’s any huge revelation at this point SLB.
No guardian for me tonight so expect to get munched.
Miked is very analytical and I'm sure would normally set me straight properly if wrong but not at all convinced by his short responses.
Moog in the frame for me too.
Ashdon too - keeps labouring the 'why did you @ Harrow point?' when anyone can look back at Day 1 and see that after giving him a chance to play, I set out (with probabilities attached) why he was the only logical one to vote which several people agreed swayed them.
Seer - be very precise with your messages tomorrow and explain rationale and previous viewings if you make it through the night!
I’m sorry Cthulhu. I’m going with the crowd here. I don’t think either moog or norn are evil, but other than that I have no clue.
I know the right thing normally in this game is to lynch a named evil. But the risk is today that, if Message 3 is genuine, we risk killing off a good player and learning nothing.
So you agree then? Only set it out as Miked seems adamant it's not correct.
What do we learn from lynching someone not named? Even less! And surely that's also a risk of losing one of team good?
See Mike's attempts to argue otherwise
oh I definitely agree on that point yes.
SLB - your card is marked. Cthulhu you have my vote today.
For what it’s worth and to echo my earlier posing - message 1 looks evil, message 2 looks confusing, and message 3 looks most consistent with Day 1’s message 2, which by the powers of deduction, I am inclined to believe is good.
I’m hoping for some protection tonight, Mr/Mrs Guardian.
You're going to eat me tonight?
I kind of agree that without the code (which I have no idea about) there's no definitive way to tell, however, I guess I'm predisposed to believe that 3 is the message as it's correct about me and, I suspect, about Norn.
"Cthulhu?" The mason questioned.
"Yes" he answered meekly.
"You have been found guilty of tagging a known wolf, Harrow Orn"
"I did but, it was an innocent thing to do" he reassured the crowd.
"Case closed", the mason asserted, "You must face your fate; or more specifically the fate, I mean frying pan, with hit your face!".
The pan was swung at Cthulhu, it hit him hard and he went down. He didn't get up, he eyes were open and fixed, then a trickle of red blood run out of his ear.
Cthulhu was good.
Night players please send me your choices by 11pm.