Inevitable demise , I grant you she is probably on borrowed time as am I , but you seem so certain ,Is she your next target?
No. The wolves know the guardian cannot protect her so will go for the easy kill. If I was a wolf, I’m not sure it would be a very clever move to announce all of my future kills on here first, so that everyone could see my guilt...
Interesting ,so are you putting her on a things to kill later when were bored list? to be fair to you there has been a few players who have made the obligatory one post then disappeared
Still no idea. I'm either being an idiot or you're being far too cryptic. Anyway, I assume you are trying to tell us you are the Guardian so even if you did survive the lynching, surely you'd be an easy target for a wolf? So don't understand why you'd do that. The only 'potential' clues you refer to are the fact Dom mentions in the write up HH asking the Guardian wanted a drink (extremely tedious and coincidental link to you running the bar?). Other than that, the gridiron newspaper might be you trying to refer to the Guardian newspaper somehow but I've no idea how.
I thought both wolves found out each other’s identity. But this post suggests only one knows the other: The beast yelped in anguish and fled. Outside, the other beast sat and observed the spectacle. It knew not to attack and it also knew who the other beast was. I can’t see it, but I did brush through yesterday’s thread very quickly. Will I learn more by looking at day 1, or are all the clues in day 2?
The guardian's presence was the anomaly, was wondering what happened had the guardian not been there.
I will patiently wait for you in the graveyard and explain all last clue think wizard of Oz think anagrams. ok I am leaving work and then have to go out so I have to vote now .
Actually scratch that. From page 1 of the rules thread: IF two wolves pick the same person to kill over night - they will learn of each others identities.
Ah, I get the Wizard of Oz one and noticed another one from earlier. I'm afraid I can't see you surviving the lynching though.
This is all very confusing but unfortunately I wont have time to wait for more information as I'm not going to make it to my destination in time to vote later. Sorry Norway at this point I'm not sure who else to go for and I have to vote now. Really hope you're not the guardian...
It seems Norway's posts came from cryptic but we all missed it until he spelt it out. So has gone a roundabout way of broadcasting it. If Norway does turn out to be good, then I have a few suspects but Miked2006 is not one of them.
If the guardian can vote for themselves then we could spare Norway and ask for him to save himself tonight. If he saves himself, then we have know he’s the guardian. If so, we’d have one more day with a member of team good, who could potentially sway a vote in our favour tomorrow. If he doesn’t save himself, we’d know he’s evil and that’s essentially a guaranteed team evil kill tomorrow.
Right, I have to go out on various chauffeur duties so need to vote now. Sorry Norway, but since you're the only named "evil" and since I don't feel I can justify lynching someone random, I'm going to have to vote for you. And if there are any extra protection powers out there, please could someone use them on me tonight!
Hi all, sorry for radio silence. I've skimmed the thread. From what I can sum up: Scenario 1: Message 2 today is from the wolf, naming Cassetti and Cthulhu as good, meaning that Norway is evil (or tinker) and Harrow is good and the natures of Cassette and Cthulhu is completely unknown, though with the wolves knowing each other, it's possible a clumsy wolf has tried to clear the Beta (Cassetti). Scenario 2: Message 1 today is from the wolf, meaning that Cassetti and Cthulhu are confirmed good and that Norway has been named evil at random. Scenario 1 is the best for team good, as it gives us two framed people to Lynch (Norway and Cassetti), however, instinct is leading me towards Scenario 2 being more likely, just because of writing style and the messages themselves. Agree?
I just realised that although Message 2 today names Cthulhu, it doesn't necessarily mean it was posted by whoever named Cthulhu as good yesterday, because Message 1 today did not summarise their previous "viewing." Still, I think it more likely that the two messages naming Cthulhu came from the same person.
In rural Suffolk today. No signal for phone until now. I’m going with my gut instinct from yesterday and that’s Norway
Messages together for comparison: 12.13 m1 Hi Villagers , I had to take a random guess to begin with today as their was obviously nothing to go on. I can confirm that Cthulhu is good. Let's wait until we get a second message before throwing accusations. Your Seer 1:47 m2 Greetings Villagers, Looks like the wolf got impatient and posted first. With nothing to go on, randomly chosen is Harrow Orn. Harrow Orn is good. Let's hope for better luck tomorrow. Your Seer 9:42: d2 m1 Hi Villagers, Great work by the Guardian last night. Due to some suspicions I have checked Norwayhornet and we are in luck - NorwayHornet is evil. Your Seer 10:25 d2 m2 Hi Villagers , Again, I didn't have too much to go on this morning as the only thing I knew for sure was that Cthulhu was good. I decided to take the advice of some posters from yesterday and view Cassetti's Beard. I can confirm that Cassetti's Beard is good. I didn't view Norway as I know both wolves know each other so at the very worst he is an unlucky traitor, unless of course the alpha is playing a brave game and naming the other wolf as evil to throw us off the scent. Do not lynch Cthulhu or Cassetti's Beard, their both good. Your Seer
My point earlier was that if message 1 was the seer, I can't see any scenario where the wolf wouldn't post a random good player as being evil, particularly as the wolves know each other. Therefore message 2 must have been from the seer. I also suspect that we have a very clever wolf here. Firstly copying the style for message 2 allowed us to lynch someone good, secondly as the alpha wolf knows who the other wolf is they could randomly name anyone as evil in the knowledge that he couldn't get the wolf by mistake, worst case from the wolf's point of view would be selecting a traitor. As it is usual for the seer to post first, I think this brazen wolf leapt on an opportunity to post like this to get us to lynch Norway. If Norway does also happen to be the guardian then that's a bonus for team evil. Therefore I believe that Norway is not a wolf, but our Alpha is among today's early posters; namely nornironhorn, Grrrwood and Horace are all on my radar and hiding in plain sight.
The more I read the messages the less certain I am of anything. I keep changing my mind about who they are from.
So my thoughts: D1 M2 message giver went from Greeting Villagers to Hi Villagers. The seer nearly always stays consistent, and so this looks like an attempt to copy the seers style. This makes me think that D1 M2 is from the wolf. As D1 M1 and D2 M2 says to save Cthulu, then D2 M1 is likely from the wolf. This means that Norway, the Guardian, is likely to die tonight.
