Summerwolf - Chapter 3 'the Greater Good'

Are we struggling to figure out which message is the seer? I thought we had that pretty nailed earlier so I’m unsure why you have (twice) said it’s not clear?

 

Yeah but I meant a guaranteed one

 

Am off to the pub so I'm going to be voting Tony now. That vote on BRLR reeks. Cthulhu has voted too but he's 99.9% confirmed as good.

 

I’ve gone for Ashdon. In fairness it was a bit of a toss up but the exchange with Otter the other day has been playing on my mind.

 

Because I’m catching up and I hit reply before reaching the end of the thread?

 

I'm voting in ten as I'm heading to the pub. For me it's either:

Dom: trying to distract and saying lots of things that are incorrect or simply confusing himself.
Ashton: Playing dumb as a clever player, but does Otter hinting he's on his side make him look more or less guilty
Tony: Playing up to being a newbie, but did a very clever bit of research then tried to potentially out a seer. Also did a strange early vote.

 

That's just the smell of my cooking

 

I really don’t know which way to vote. I’ve been suspicious of BRLR from Day 1 - and his excuse now that he’s ‘so bad at this game’ when he was talking like he was on Day 1 only fuels my suspicion.

That said - I can’t quite reason why Otter voted for him on Day 1 after Otter met his demise! So I tend to think my suspicion is maybe misguided.

Tonycotonstache and Dom are currently highest on my list but I’m holding fire a bit to see if anyone else says anything suspicious!

 

Haha, nice try.

 

Rookie error from me. Won't happen again if I'm still alive for the next round.

 

Can everybody stop talking about going to the pub whilst I’m isolating and housebound

 

I'm going to cast my vote now as I don't envisage myself being around the laptop for too much longer this evening.

I don't understand the heat on me for one moment when you think back to what led to (what we think was) the Seer's Day 2 viewing on Harrow, who was subsequently cleared. I would suggest the Seer views me on Monday, if I live to see the weekend to confirm the lay of the land.

I don't understand a lot of what seems to be going on with the voting, but that's just where we're at in this game at the moment. Sorry tony, rookie or not, I don't understand why you'd have likely outed the code on the probably-Seer's message, so i'm voting for you today i'm afraid.

 

I'm minded to vote for Dom.

My theory is that Otter was in fact a wolf rather than Traitor and that Dom is the traitor. His posts are either to lead us all offtrack or they are just terribly confusing for a Good player.

In either case he's no loss

 

Why not vote for someone with more votes, like Ashdon or Tony, if you know you're good and you don't know if they are?

 

CLARIFICATION - if there is a tie my hat will once again be called into service.

 

Are you trying to save WT?

 

10 votes so far out of 18.

And still no real consensus!

 

Nice anniversary meal out with Mrs D tonight so voting now. TonyCotonsTache gets my vote only because he's posting such suspicious stuff and that's literally all I have.
I think I know the Seer.

 

WT didn't have any votes. Other players had 2 votes, with less than half the votes left.

If I knew I was good, and I didn't know the role of two other players who already had 2 votes, I'd go for the more suspicious player of the two to save myself, then put a message in the chat explaining that I would have voted for WT but self preservation etc.

You can see my views on every player earlier in the thread. WT is really weirdly and suspiciously quiet, but we have nothing at this stage to say good or evil. Being that quiet probably isn't a deliberate wolf tactic, as it is going to attract more attention than saying a few nothing statements each day as many on here seem to be doing.

 

Fair enough. Had to ask!

 

Ooh where did you go? There was a nice rock with some succulent limpets on the weather side of the island.

 

Dom has made his way to the top of my list as the day has gone on.

But Tonycotonstache move earlier makes it really hard to ignore him.

That’s where my current thoughts are.

 

Had to vote as busy tonight so stuck with my gut and went for Dom. Again, not a massive amount to go on but some strange posting, and no one else has really stuck out for me. Sorry dom!

 

I’ve gone BRLR as I think he’s a bit dodgy and following Cthulhu as the only confirmed Good player.

Rest of the mud slinging is all based on hunches.

 

Kings Aaaaaarms matey

 

Dom on 5
BRLR on 3
Tonycotonstache on 3
Ashdon on 2

15 votes out of 18 cast (I’m one of 3 not yet voted)

Would be nice to hear compelling reasons from each of the above as to why they shouldn’t be voted for!

 

From past games the worst thing we can do is have a draw. That's all I can advise.

 

Anyone know who the other 2 are who haven’t voted?

 

1. I love puzzles and overdid trying to understand this game by getting too caught up sleuthing.
2. I am trying to be an active player and not lurk unlike others.
3. I really think next week if I'm still around I'll have got the hang of it all.

 

Sod it.

Sorry Dom. But numbers did it for me - and not been able to remove my suspicion all day!