Cheers I will say that if Grrwood is good then the seer should also consider looking at Myself, as I have lead to push towards Grrwood.
My only nagging thought is that the second message was the wolf's. And the wolf isn't going to name beta.
Morning all. Just signing in. Pretty surprised the wolves didn't kill me off, though probably as I'm doing more harm than good!!!! Sorry Cthulhu. I really did suspect you from day 1 and all your actions were a little wolflike. I still firmly believe SLB is the Harlot. I have a few ideas on others byt think maybe best not to lead anyone today!!!
Kill off my own brother Dom? Fraticide is not one of my beliefs. I still firmly believe that daft row was the tinker and that slb is the harlot. The only way at this stage he cannot be the harlot is if ybot was. I think the second message is from the wolf and I don't think the wolf would implicate another wolf this early on meaning that most likely both Dom and grrwood are good.
I agree the seer should look at one of the 6 who voted for both DR and CTH. However I think it should be one of those that posted more often as they are more likely to be the Traitor no ? Am happy to hear your thoughts on why NW Orn though, although I think we should steer clear of voting for those just because they ve not posted often
Don't forget Ashdon and Mike. If SLB has managed to call himself out and hit the jackpot that the Harlot was one of three that had already been killed, then I'll be asking him to pick out my lottery numbers next week
It can't be Ashdon and Mike though as they were both killed in their own homes, the only other possible person it could be is ybot.
Just checking in as work is busy. Had a very quick read through and think we're back at the point of either lynching someone named as evil (who might be good) or a total randomer (just as likely to be good). The latter hasn't worked out too well so far!
Happy to take your word for it! Harrow, just to double check, this game was the same as last right in regards to roles being randomly assigned?
Oh well in that case the point is moot. Slb is definitely the harlot. If any other player is the harlot and has not revealed themselves by this point then they are detrimental to the cause. On that basis SLB is good, which leaves only Grrwood as being viewed evil. I thought the general consensus today is that the second message is the wolf. Unless it is a double bluff surely grrwood is also good.
Yep just checked. Likely to be "Quite Good" definitely not just "Good" so the Harlot can't of been any of those who have died. Next!
BigRossLittleRoss Otter Steve Leo Beleck (Harlot?) Grrwood (Named as evil Day 4) With A Smile (Mentioned in message 2 on Day 4) Squibba (Named as good day 3) HappyHornet24 Meh Hornetgags Domthehornet (Named as good day 4) Steve Harrow PowerJugs NW Orn Optimistichornet (Named as good day 3) Thought this might help but it didn't one bit, honestly I have individual reasons for being suspicious of everyone probably bar Otter. Looking like it has to be Grrwood. Although, whilst typing I am wondering who on earth SLB has actually saved by being the Harlot? It's a bit pointless right now..
Squibba in the interest of openness I've actually only been mentioned as good. I personally think that message was the wolf.
If he doesn't need to name those Good then that's what I'd do, only reason to out those confirmed Good would be to save them from Lynching. However, I will say that because the Wolves know each other now the only reason not to say would be in the hope they attack the Traitor by mistake, though that's about it from where I stand and previous experience. Those confirmed Good either by a Seer message OR by SLB naming those he knows are Good would be dead in a day or two as the Wolves would know they're safe kills.
By "named" I should've said "mentioned". I didn't mean it confirmed you were Good. Apologies for confusion!
Haha, fair point Squibba. I have been pointless so far! I guess the only hope is that at some point Team Evil go for someone I've stayed with and then I can categorically state it's a stitch up.
Well, brilliant. Finally all caught up on my lunch break and quite rightly I will be number one suspect today. Very disappointing that the seer didn't hit an evil view today and I am now being framed by the wolf. WAS has tried to point fingers at me from day 1, but I think it wouldn't make sense for him to frame me in a message when he's already turning heads against me, so I don't think he's the Alpha wolf (maybe second wolf?) I suspect the wolf has jumped on WAS's hysteria for an easy framing. I understand that going for a quieter player at this point is the game is a pretty reasonable idea, this time just misguided unfortunately. I do fully expect to be lynched tonight though, well played wolfie.
Back for an hour or so. To those questioning whether those killed could have been the harlot, I addressed this yesterday; they would have been "quite good". The fact that neither message today refers to viewing SLB as "evil" makes me even more convinced that was a wolf's message. Or we have a very unhelpful Seer! I have no idea which message today is which and, sadly, the only thing to do is to lynch one of the named "evils". It has to be Grrwood for me.
I've bit my tongue because this kinda implicates me too but me and Opti were both named as Good yesterday. I know I'm good (obviously anyone would say this) but I just can't work out why a wolf would name Opti as good? Makes no sense to me. And Day 3 is too early for Opti to play a double bluff isn't it!? So confused
If you are right, it would make sense for a wolf to name another random player as good, to keep SLB in the frame and to maintain confusion over which message is which.
If I was playing a double bluff squibba I would be the boldest wolf ever. To do it on day 3 would be suicidal. I am good.
As an experienced player, I can't see you making that move on Day 3 to be honest so I'm going to trust you on this one!
