Summer Werewolf II - Day 2

Diamond is yet to be seen if we agree the Ashdon viewing was correct as Diamond was called Good by the Wolf yesterday. Otherwise you're correct. Unless it's a case of Wolf calls DR / SLB Evil and the other is a Tinker then in which case why are we so ******* unlucky?

 

Answer the first postulate?

 

Called as Evil by the Wolf. The Seer would simply view them as Good as proven by me last game. See the first Messages on the first day last game for reference.

 

I do believe that SLB is the Harlot. DR has also said something in particular that makes me think they are a villager. This leads me to one conclusion only, and that is that DR is the tinker. Again, with 25 players this would be incredibly unlucky for team good, but not unlikely.
With the above in mind there is no choice but to vote for Daft Row tonight. See you in hell, possibly.

 

A brain?

 

What's that?

 

Something I'd prefer to keep to myself for the time being.

 

I have to say I'm siding with DR this time.

If we lynch SLB tonight and it turns out he is the harlot it's not like we ve lost a high powered GOOD because the harlot is still as likely to be eaten by wolf as a normal GOOD, because who ever he stays with has the same chance as the harlot as being picked .

So we affectiveley have a 50/50 chance of lynching a good whoever we pick and DRs actions seems more in line with a normal villager . SLB may or may not be right in his thought processes but his actions also arouse some suspicions especially outing himself in this way.

I think it is a safer bet to lynch SLB first and if he is the harlot then we lynch DR tomorrow and get an evil guaranteed and only lost a harlot which is nt very powerful when everyone knows who it is.

 

See this is my thinking, but with 2 people named guilty and the other clearly named by the wolf surely we have to go for SLB or Daft Row. I don't really understand the harlot concept but if villagers seem to think we should let SLB prove themself I guess we have to go for Daft Row.

 

I meant answer this... If Daft Row was furry, then why didn't he claim to be the harlot?

 

You might be right to be honest.

 

The fact it named me as Evil when I know I'm the Harlot!

 

I'm not comfortable with this suggestion that the real harlot has to come out to disprove SLB. That may be exactly what evil want and it's not fair to pressurise someone to disclose an especially good role. If he is good, only he will know and anyone that says otherwise are surely guessing? Aren't we all mind you...

 

If I was stupid enough to do that then I certainly wouldn't be insulting Squibba.

Anyway, voted Daft Row as my mind is made up that Steve is the Harlot, (and I'm not following the sheep by hiding in the flock later).

 

You just said you didn't think it was me... and I know why. So frustrating, you're going to lead the flock, far worse then hide in it.

 

Just a small point but we know for definite that the Ashdon Good message was the Seer. Both messages today say it was, so at least one of them has to be from the real Seer. There is therefore no doubt that the Seer viewed Ashdon and the Wolf posted the message about Diamond on Day 1.

 

Also if you think I am the Tinker it proves that SLB is still EVIL as he was viewed as EVIL and has expressed that he is the Harlot.

This is why I know for certain that SLB is EVIL.

 

That doesn't make sense. If the Seer viewed you and saw you as Evil because you were the Tinker, then the Wolf named me.

 

Not necessarily, if the second message was the wolf's then SLB hasn't actually ben seen.

 

Utter drivel. I'm not even going to explain why if the others can't work it out.

 

Ross your logic is completely flawed. Steve has outed himself as the harlot, daft row only maintains his innocence. If he had said that he was the harlot early doors then you would be correct. Safest bet in the absence of another harlot post is to go for daft row.

 

Yep, take that back as SLB mention of EVIL could have been from Wolf post. But come on... odds on me being the Tinker twice in a row?

 

Don - Even if he is not a harlot, and there is no harlot then he could of course be evil. It wouldn't be the first time that a wolf has inadvertently named another evil player. I've done that at least once.

 

Would help Team GOOD though?

 

The one thing that confuses me is about SLB is

In post #27 ( i think ) he says that he doesn't trust the first message, which he then contradicts throughout the thread, claiming the first post to be from the seer.

 

All SLB has done is create a load of confusion, typical EVIL characteristic. I plead with you all to vote for him in the next four hours.

 

I've voted SLB, gut instinct told me earlier that the first message was the wolf's and the second was the seer's. However there's very little to go on in finding out which is genuine. Both players are 50/50 IMO but SLB's posts just seem a touch too desperate.

PS I have an inkling that HH24 is the traitor.

 

I have a terrible feeling that SLB and Daft Row are good but accept we have to lynch one of them today.

Re the messages and styles, I think there's a danger of seeing what you want to see there. As shown by SLB changing his mind earlier, we don't know which is from the seer and which is from the alpha or beta wolf. Did we even clear up whether alpha died last night by the way?

Guesswork tonight. Again.

 

Emmm interesting. I think she has a role, but our thinking is different, but you might not be to wide of the mark, were probably thinking along the same lines.

I think there have been a lot more leading the pack where they want them to go.

I will throw a possibility into the equation - what if DR and SLB are both evil ?

 

I'm voting now as I'm on call this evening, and might not otherwise get a chance.

I'm voting for daft row. In the absence of another harlot it is the sensible thing to do today. Either way if daft row is innocent today we lynch slb tomorrow. That being said if daft row is lynched today and evil we can still lynch slb tomorrow as the wolf could have wrongly implicated him.

Sorry daft row but I'm sticking to my guns from earlier.

 

I understand.