Day 2

Discussion in 'Anonymous Werewolf' started by miked2006, Jun 16, 2020.

?

Day 2 lynching

  1. Athens

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  2. Berlin

    92.9%
  3. Cancun

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  4. Denver

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  5. Helsinki

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  6. Istanbul

    7.1%
  7. Moscow

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  8. Nairobi

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  9. Quito

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  10. Santiago

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  11. Tokyo

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  12. Jeddah

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  13. Fes

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  14. Zagreb

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Zagreb

    Zagreb Academy Graduate

    It seems likely that the second message is the Wolf, copying the Seer.

    It seems bad tactics for Berlin to out himself as Seer so early in the day.

    It seems Berlin has made a mistake in referring to the pther message as the Seer.

    Not looking good for Berlin.
     
  2. Zagreb

    Zagreb Academy Graduate

    Looking likely there ll be a full moon tonight.
     
  3. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    You don't out yourself as the Seer unless the vote is going against you. It's an od move.

    On the other hand Istanbul is being way to aggressive in defending himself and pointing fingers at others from the start. That's also odd behaviour for a Wolf so I'm leaning towards Berlin right now.
     
  4. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    Dammit, I hate that you can't edit posts to rectify spelling mistakes.
     
  5. Moscow

    Moscow Academy Graduate

    Yeah given the time of day and where play was at, very strange for Berlin to give that up. In other games, that's nearly always a last resort move. Nobody had voted, there was plenty of time to propose a theory to sway the voting without rendering our Seer useless moving forward.

    Could also just be an inexperienced player though.
     
  6. Cancun

    Cancun Academy Graduate

    Wow! That’s a lot to catch up on. A definite evil named and a seer who’s possibly outed themselves/wolf trying to cover their tracks. Going to have a look back over both Berlin and Istanbul’s posts. But, whatever happens today, at least we have a definite evil going today or tomorrow. And no traitor left to protect the last evil left. Things are looking much better for Team Good this time round.
     
  7. Zagreb

    Zagreb Academy Graduate

    Yeah but as it s so early, there ll be a full moon tonight so we ll be back to two wolves again.
     
  8. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    The number one question is why Berlin referred to the other message as being from the Seer. Some of the rest of the stuff could just be noise. But doing that would be an impossible mistake to make if you were the Seer.
     
  9. Cancun

    Cancun Academy Graduate

    True but at least there won’t be a traitor.
     
  10. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    The choice today is easy at least. Berlin or Istanbul. Don't assume the other is good even if we lynch an Evil tonight. We've been given a great start and need to keep up the work.
     
  11. Quito

    Quito Academy Graduate

    I’m leaning towards Berlin purely based upon the ‘mistake’ and outing himself in strange circumstances.

    I expect I will get a defensive rebuke - but I don’t agree with @Denver that Istanbul has been pretty aggressive in going after Berlin - and that raises suspicions too with me. He/she could just be trying to understandably defend their position in the game however.
     
  12. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    Berlin has had a mare today especially with outing themselves accidentally. He's got my vote.
     
  13. Tokyo

    Tokyo Academy Graduate

    It is annoying but it has meant Berlin couldn't edit his post saying seers message rather than wolf!
     
  14. Zagreb

    Zagreb Academy Graduate

    Yup, Im going Berlin, unless something special happens today.
     
  15. Istanbul

    Istanbul Academy Graduate

    I agree with Denver that I've been vocal in terms of suggestions (eg Venice is unlikely to be very good) and suspicions (eg Denver not mentioning the interaction between them and London) but don't feel I've done anything towards Berlin that another named player would do differently.
     
  16. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Well let's see if Berlin can take a bit of time over lunch to come and provide some explanations otherwise he looks a goner!
     
  17. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    Berlin’s silence is damning at the moment with regards to answering Istanbul’s questions.

    May be establishing how to dig himself out of the hole he’s made for himself.

    As it stands, this is where my vote will be going, and if it proves misguided at least we know where we can focus on Day 3.
     
  18. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    We've got some early votes on Berlin already. OK I understand Istanbuls but why not give Berlin the chance to explain himself Athens?
     
  19. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    Would a Wolf masterstroke be to name themselves as evil in message 2? If Berlin is indeed evil then the mob may think the 2nd named evil is in fact good.
     
  20. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Trying to work out in what universe that would be a masterstroke.
     
    Moscow likes this.
  21. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    An accidental early vote on my part
     
  22. Istanbul

    Istanbul Academy Graduate

    I don't think you give the 'mob' much credit here. If Berlin is evil we know for certain that Quito is good. That is it, nothing else. We will know nothing about Nairobi and myself. Every player here knows that - we've all played before (numerous times).
     
  23. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    FFS, accidental? All you do when you say that is bring heat on yourself. What's going on with this game?
     
  24. Cancun

    Cancun Academy Graduate

    Berlin has disappeared it seems.
     
  25. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    Tbf I do think Berlin is the wolf so I have voted for them anyway. Istanbul's accusatory behaviour is completely un wolf like.
     
  26. Nairobi

    Nairobi Academy Graduate

    Unless the alpha named Berlin as evil by mistake. Could still mean Quito is evil.

    Unlikely but possible.

    Anyway, a full moon tonight and no one is confirmed good again.
     
    Istanbul likes this.
  27. Cancun

    Cancun Academy Graduate

    That would be a very ballsy - and risky - move by the wolf. Highly unlikely in my opinion. Also, that would mean that one evil player would definitely be lynched (either the one viewed by the Seer or the wolf himself). A wolf wouldn’t want that. More likely that whichever one the wolf has named today - either Berlin or Istanbul - is a random pick by the wolf and is still unknown re good or evil.
     
  28. Nairobi

    Nairobi Academy Graduate

    The Berlin wall of silence.
     
    Tokyo and Cancun like this.
  29. Quito

    Quito Academy Graduate

    Could. But doesn’t. :)
     
  30. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    So options here:

    Wolf chooses Berlin who is actually the Seer: 1/13 chance. Then Berlin the Seer finds an evil: 1/4 (3 out of 12 players)

    Wolf chooses Berlin who is actually Evil: 2/13 chance (2 Evils, wolf only knows for sure that he is Evil). The Seer then finds another Evil: 2/12 chance (knows 2 confirmed Goods, himself and yesterday's view)

    Seer views Berlin who is Evil (3/12 chance). Wolf has to then select someone as Evil (100% likely).

    Options 1 and 2 require two events with low probability, Option 3 only one. Unless of course my rudimentary maths is total nonsense!
     
  31. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    To me the first message is from the seer as it is too ballsy for a wolf to claim someone evil on the second day leaving them open to be viewed by the seer who could disregard the claim. The second message smacks of desperation throwing a second name out as evil.
     
  32. Tokyo

    Tokyo Academy Graduate

    I'd like to hear from Berlin before deciding for sure but he has to be the number 1 suspect. And if he's good, Istanbul gets the (karate) chop tomorrow.

    Actually hoping we lynch the harlot traitor tonight as if we kill a wolf, there will probably be a full moon anyway and we'd be no further forward.
     
  33. Berlin

    Berlin Academy Graduate

    Sorry all I’m busy working today so will have to be my last post.

    As to a couple of questions:

    Seer was a typo, i was meant to put ‘ ‘ either side but I was typing on my phone.

    As to the second question regarding the full stops, I think your probably reading too much into it again i have had to write various messages on different devices and one seems to autocorrect to adding a space before a full stop.

    As for my chances today I fully expect to be voted off. I left it late this morning to make my view as the seer and the wolf beat me to the punch.

    If as expected I go at the end of today then please just promise me that Istanbul goes tomorrow.

    Message for my replacement as seer my next steps were going to be to view Athens and Santiago.

    Unfortunately I was probably going to have to drop out of the game at the end of the day anyway as we have a very poorly family member.

    All the best Berlin.
     
  34. Quito

    Quito Academy Graduate

    I don’t know what to make of 99% of @Berlin message there.

    But given the last part about his family and being unable to continue the game, I’d say that’s decision made. And @Istanbul’s fate rests on the outcome...
     
  35. Istanbul

    Istanbul Academy Graduate

    Sorry to hear about your family member, hope they get better soon.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page