Pozzowolf Day 3

Are you querying which messages on days 1 and 2 messages are good and evil?

 

Not at all.

 

Mutiny? How would that work?

 

Players not knowing each other so early in the game. Inadvertently then put a spotlight on other players - good or bad. I've done it before in games hence why I tend to apply rubbish banter in the threads when there isn't much to go on. I'd rather try and add something than be called out for being inactive!

I feel like a suffer the same fate as Skyla in these games. Try and keep the chats going and then get jumped on for mistyping a word or a number. Don't say so much and get jumped on the same way.

This game drives me mad every time!

 

Very difficult game so far, really not much to go on.

 

Just a few questions... Have you read my earlier message? How are you using my third to last vote for an evil character against me? When without my vote it would have been a draw? That should be applauded should it not? Is it possible you're the one that's been promoted to Pozzo hierarchy?

 

Let's take a look at the relevant messages so far:

-----------------------------------------------------

Anonymous Message #1 - Received 9:59 (Seer)

Good morning fellow Watfordites! It is your wise old seer here. This morning I viewed steve harrow - he is GOOD. Sorry I couldn't have been of more use. See you on the training pitches.

42/4/O

-------------------------------------------------------

Anonymous message #2 - Received 12:49 (Seer)

Good afternoon fellow Watfordites! It is your wise old seer here again. I viewed Cthulhu - they are GOOD. Bummer.
Yesterday I viewed steve harrow, who was GOOD.

41/4/U

------------------------------------------------------

Anonymous message #1 - received 12:12 (Unknown)

Good afternoon my Watford chums. Gino has an awful hangover, so it looks like your wise old seer will have to blink first today.

Today I viewed Cassetti's Beard - they are GOOD. Darn it!

Previously I viewed Cthulhu and steve harrow, who were both GOOD.

Hopefully I can be of more use tomorrow!

40/5/E

------------------------------------------------------

Anonymous message #2 - Received 12:21 (Unknown)

Good afternoon fellow Watfordites! It is your wise old seer here again. I viewed Daft Row - they are EVIL. Yesterday I viewed Cthulhu - they are GOOD. I also viewed steve harrow, who is GOOD. Better.

40/4/T

----------------------------------------------------

To me the 4th message looks like a blatant copy of the second. I have put in italics some wording that looks more naturally similar to me, and not a copy paste job. This, combined with the fact the messages came in quick succession today, would make me lean towards today's first message being from the seer.

 

Above post made me realise I've named players as good that may not be due to the board promotion. I also got the numbers wrong. So I believe if we avoid me we have a 1 in 3 opportunity to get an evil tonight, assuming two wolves and traitor.

Breakdown below, please all scrutinise and let me know your thoughts.

GOOD (Confirmed by Seer)

• CB

GOOD (Up to you to decide, not viewed by real Seer yet)

• Daft Row

UNSURE (Confirmed good by Seer, but could have been promoted to board since then)

• Cthulhu - Let's see where the conversation goes from here...
• Steve Harrow - Makes logical points. Such as ww and H81 named as good by Gino.

UNKNOWN

• Dom - Has backed my logic on Skyla and believes first message is Seer. But could be playing games, and no guarantee Skyla is good. Especially after the promotion to the board.
• Hornets81 - Quiet. Named as good by Gino, red flag?
• SkylaRose - If evil they should have thrown an evil view in yesterdays message to distract. However there has been a promotion to the board since then and their partner in evil may have been the Alpha and not have helped! Agrees second message is likely from wolf as they waited for Seer to post first.
• tonycotonstache – Not posting anything of much value? Lots of ‘idle chat’.
• TomWatfordWFC - Agreed that I would have been an odd Seer viewing. Thinks yesterday’s Seer message was the correct one. Doesn’t mean much though.
• watford willy - Following the crowd. No reasoning. Named as good by Gino, red flag?
• wfcMoog –Sporadic accusations, Moog being Moog. However very confident second message is wolf.

 

Very good point - I'd forgotten about this!

 

sugar, yes. I'd been working on the assumption that Cthulhu, CB and Steve were all named good, presuming the first message was the Seer, however, last night's promotion throws a spanner into the works.

 

TCT
Dom
Skyla
Hornets81
Tom
Daft Row
Watford Willy
(me)

Working with what we do know, rather than what we don't know, at least 2, but probably at least 3 of the above are evil Pozzo scum.

I wouldn't be too quick to rule out the newbies as having key roles either. That they were named in the message by what is 99% Pozzo, is neither here nor there really. Could be a random guess by their unknowing evil ally. Could be inexperienced players trying an obvious play to name themselves as good.

I know it's not a hugely helpful narrowing down of the list but I'm voting for one of the above tonight (not myself) and I'm hoping over the next hour or so we can come to a consensus of which we should choose, bearing in mind that there are probably 3 among us who have a very different agenda to the rest.

 

I'm gonna have to vote soon. Evenings are too busy 6-8 and it's likely I'll forget otherwise.

Last call for anyone to give some input before I check a box.

 

If you are going to be voting me for my typo. Bummer.

 

If you are unsure about Cthulu and I then you're either a wrong un or daft.

 

It's just as possible as anyone else though right? Attempting to be completely unbiased and fair... as your posts have been all day.

 

The point is that you could have been good and then 'promoted' to evil as per the write up yesterday.

As I've said though, with that logic we can't eliminate anyone apart from CB

 

Three hours to vote people.

 

Very forceful in all this today aren't you.

 

If you say so?

 

Fair point on the promotion. I hadn't thought of that so humble pie being scoffed

 

I just think you are drawing a lot of attention in a very low activity day three, with so many quick responses and rationales. If I'm getting called out for one typo being misleading, maybe the big step up in detective work is as much to cover some of Team Evils mistakes today as a number error?

Fair point no?

 

Okay then, how about a bold claim... Daft Row is Nigel Pearson.

 

Too safe Skyla. Totally agree.

 

Not trying to avoid leading any votes but only half read some posts from this afternoon so will need to look more when home.

I'm good.
I think Cthulu has a greater chance of being good than anyone else.

 

To back this up, there has been a marked shift in play style, yesterday they voted as a good (imo), and today they are keen to point out that Cthulhu and steve harrow could have been turned. The person most likely to do that? The person who was actually NP. I'll kick off proceedings. Sorry DR, nothing personal.