Bump, this thread makes for interesting reading. Thank god we've kept dodging this bullet (I know Carthorse was also crap today, but this guy has never been the answer).
I'd still rather have Kabak than Cathcart, though. He's as good/better than him now, and he's only 21 so very young for a CB. So struggling to mock those in the thread who wanted to sign him, tbh
Fear not. Soon I will be able to spend hours trawling though old posts and dig up his mocking of my prediction that Brighton would finish in midtable
The main problem with our defence is the lack of depth, we'd be in serious doodoo if Kabak were playing regularly for us by the looks of it, but I suppose as a 5th choice he'd be better than literally nobody
Verdict - gash. The giveaway was when Nat Phillips was the better player in their partnership at Liverpool.