The biggest crime was not getting rid of Grrwood the day before, when the seer message had made it very likely that he was evil. Kill Grrwood that day, and you'd only lose 1 of Otter and Cthulhu. One of the above would very likely have picked Happy. @Grrwood Which one did you take out? Killing Horace would have been more difficult, unless the seer had a very good game.