I'm voting NW Orn as I may have to leave soon. Suspicious behaviour, dodgy voting patterns, sorry NW. I know I'm good which means the wolf named Opti as good and I can't see Opti playing that double bluff this early, too risky.
I've already answered you SLB. I'm on my phone so can't type a long response . In summary it was never categorically stated and if I made a wrong assumption then I won't be alone in making that error today . I find your over sensitivity to me questioning you using sound logic as slightly suspicious . And as for blundering you ve done a fine job of outing CB and wasting a guardian just to save your little old self . Surely a good harlot would be willing to sacrifice themselves for team good ...so far we ve lost DR, Diamond , CB is outed and you ve outed yourself . And you call me a blunderer ? I wouldn't say your stupid as your logic is good you re just extremely selfish . Thye talk about elephants in the room , wel you're an unexploded grenade
I need to leave work now and can't guarantee I'll be back on line before the deadline so I'm voting early. Going for Cthulhu sorry if I'm wrong.
Just been on voting ....Why is everyone voting CTH? Have I missed something ? Can someone explain ? He strikes me as good , but then So does everyone !
It's due to frustration. You replied but didn't really answer the point I raised. It is absolutely categorical that Message 2 on the first day was the Wolf. Both messages the following day said that they had viewed Ashdown. Therefore, one had to be from the Seer and thus telling the truth (irrelevant which one for this purpose). Therefore Message 2, Day 1 can only have been from the Wolf. Do you understand now? That it was 100% the Wolf saying that they would be changing styles? It was spelled out quite clearly, but you brought it up again today. Maybe you are a blunderer, I don't know.
If you are going to lynch me when it shows I'm good tonight will you then all listen and please lynch SLB?
Here is my reply to the otter post. It'll have to be quick. i refer to my very early post. Daft and SLB named as evil yesterday. Scenario 1 Daft is tinker seen by seer SLB picked by a wolf at random as evil This could be the truth, it could. Scenario 2 Daft is good and wolf calls him evil SLB is picked by seer and is evil This could also be true Ignore all the bs about who might come forward as a harlot it can't be trusted. There might be many reasons to keep quiet as harlot. So as daft says SLB is 50/50 I promise like last game if you vote me out it's a waste.
View me tomorrow if you don't believe and I live. If lynched SLB and those who've argued his case need to be suspected, and look at the patterns of liking on ALL the threads
You realise that's not a response to Otter's post at all?! You've ignored what he was talking about completely! He was talking about the events of last night and the messages today. You haven't addressed that at all, you've written quite a long post pretending you were but in fact you've only talked about yesterday's day phase and declared it a 50/50. You have completely avoided the content of Otter's post. I'll repost what Otter wrote so you can have another go: FACT having slain Diamond last night both wolves know each other. CLAIM SLB outed himself as the harlot, no one else has disputed that with a counter claim. WHY NOT? No normal villager would do that and compromise another good player dishonestly, no evil player would do that as that will give unwanted attention on themselves. If SLB was a wolf then whoever is the Alpha would have almost certainly wrote a message stating that someone else was EVIL in order to help save the wolf from a certain lynching. If SLB is the harlot as far as the wolf is concerned, then realistically the only way to get rid of them is to either be lucky or get the villagers to lynch him, hence the message randomly stating someone else is good. The only other reason for the wolf to name someone evil would have been if the seer's message was stating someone as evil. Conclusion SLB is most probably the harlot. And for the wolf not to name someone evil then message #2 must have been the wolf's, even going as far as reiterating that SLB is evil.
If you strike me down SLB I shall grow more powerful than you can possibly imagine. When I get lynched tonight and I'm good You and your cronies have done enough today to hopefully give the others enough clues to get you all. I'll take that sacrifice for team good
I have to go soon. Quick change from work to class so have to vote. SLB is probably the harlot but not definite. I don't like that he asked for the "real" harlot to out themselves to prove his case nor that he confirmed CB as good without CB knowing. That's not a team player, that's someone who wants to cling on for their own sake. In summary, probably not evil but I'm not prepared to lynch someone random who is just as likely to be good.
There is no "real Harlot" Steve, that's why I can post it. I took a calculated gamble that CB wasn't going to carry on playing as he was silent all of yesterday, didn't vote and we knew he was on holiday.
Have to say I don't see why anyone good would lynch you tonight. You're as likely to be good or bad as anyone else but if you're lynched and declared good, I have to think evil have spotted something you have said and influenced enough villagers to take you out with no evidence. If you're lynched and evil however, yay. Haha.
Have to say Steve, as well as Cth being on my list you were as well since yesterday from a couple of things you said, and voting SLB to save your wolfie mate has strengthened my belief!
Won't be able to write again as am out from now on. If Cthulhu is lynched and is evil, Steve Harrow and BRLR should be viewed next. Both have voted for me despite saying I'm almost certainly good and have consistently attempted to undermine Mt status as Harlot. Have both stuck up for Cthulhu too. If Cthulhu is Good then that's two games in a row he's done a fantastic impression of a guilty person and back to the drawing board. Good luck to Team Good tonight and hope I don't get caught in bed with any of you!
stick with the facts. The true facts not what certain posters think they have deduced and are leading you all to think
Nobody's explained to me why everybody turned on CTH . I didn't see any logical argument or can I see when the tide turned against him , it seemed so random . I guess it's naievety as it's my second game which is why I'm asking ! It's too late now as he's provably gone , but there is no evidence to say CTH should be more in the frame than anyone else . My hunch is I don't think he's evil . Nothing factual to back this up other than the tone and manner of his posts . I hope you guys got it right otherwise we re going to blow the good start we had .
You've have blown it. You've been led a merry dance My hunches are just hunches above There are enough other clues around if people have the time to look. I haven't today as have been travelling as I said earlier - this is very suspicious behaviour on my part and suspicious behaviour is much more persuasive than following what actual clues we have. Let SLB guide you tomorrow and see where it gets you
Likewise BRLR, I had flimsy evidence to suggest NW Orn and was pressed to explain myself, quite rightly so, but since Cthulhu was implicated no one has really given any evidence to back up their reasoning.
Who do you think by CTH ? Seeing as you are sadly leaving us you might as well share your thoughts before HO closes the thread .
