Global Werewolf - Day 3

Discussion in 'Werewolf: The forum game' started by The Globe, Apr 29, 2020.

?

Day 3 Lynching

  1. Athens

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  2. Denver

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  3. Elche

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  4. Istanbul

    3 vote(s)
    21.4%
  5. Jeddah

    2 vote(s)
    14.3%
  6. Krakow

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  7. Moscow

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  8. Nairobi

    2 vote(s)
    14.3%
  9. Oslo

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  10. Prague

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  11. Quito

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  12. Santiago

    7 vote(s)
    50.0%
  13. Tokyo

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
  14. Venice

    0 vote(s)
    0.0%
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    Votes are hidden again? Did someone vote from a personal account?
     
  2. The Globe

    The Globe Academy Graduate

    A user has used their own account to vote by mistake so the poll has been updated as per Day 1.

    As it stands, this is how players have voted. Can you all please state who you have voted for after voting and I will update this comment as more votes are added (and also add this comment to the end of the thread for reference tomorrow)

    Jeddah: Santiago, Tokyo
    Istanbul: Nairobi*
    Nairobi: Istanbul, Prague
    Santiago: Quito, Oslo, Venice, Jeddah

    Currently one unaccounted vote for Istanbul

    Just over 1 hour remains.
     
  3. Oslo

    Oslo Academy Graduate

    Had my doubts about Santiago and Elche, went for Santiago .
     
  4. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Yet if I was, he would have granted it too - this is where your logic is flawed. I gave the scenario earlier where I destroyed the case against me. I'll put you not knowing down to ignorance rather than evilness.

    Although to have revealed yourself as a mason before the Seer and now asking other players what to do is quite shocking.
     
  5. Venice

    Venice Academy Graduate

    There's something about your posts that just don't feel right to me. I'm voting with the mason.
     
  6. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    I agree - see my earlier msg where I list who voted for Krakow on Day 1.
    I don’t think Istanbul’s early voting on Day 1 is a reason for thinking he is the Alpha, particularly since that vote went to Helsinki.
    I am intrigued by Nairobi’s voting on Day 1. In the day’s thread, he said he was looking at voting for Helsinki or Oslo, but then voted for Krakow.
     
  7. Oslo

    Oslo Academy Graduate

    If I'm wrong my apologies , now have to leave you guys to it , need to go out with the wife .
     
  8. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    My thoughts haven't changed from earlier.

    Santiago didn't vote yesterday and wasn't killed off.
    Santiago (as well as the (likely) Alpha) took the longest to accept that Oslo is a Mason.
    And Santiago voted for Krakow on day 1.

    I also suspect Nairobi (as a potential Traitor) if Santiago is evil.

    I thought Istanbul could be a potential wolf yesterday, but he quickly accepted that Oslo was a Mason today which makes him less suspicious in my opinion.
     
  9. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Great logic. I would suggest my fellow villagers take a good hard look at you and Jeddah tomorrow. You seem to have the mason under your spell (yet that doesn't seem hard), hopefully the Seer and the others focus in on you both.
     
  10. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    I've voted for Santiago.
     
  11. Quito

    Quito Academy Graduate

    Santiago gets my vote, suspected them earlier. Think they may be the traitor though.
     
  12. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Everyone remember this post and how wrong it is tomorrow.
     
  13. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    You can't believe that Oslo is the Mason AND believe Venice is evil.

    It's one or the other, surely?
     
  14. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    Woah, woah, woah. What?

    That's the easiest thing to possibly accept Oslo literally admitted it, how does that make Istanbul less suspicious?
     
  15. Venice

    Venice Academy Graduate

    They already have Santi.
     
  16. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    Look at Venice tomorrow? What are you talking about? He’s been named good today in a message even the evil players are having to acknowledge is the Seer’s.
     
    Oslo and Jeddah like this.
  17. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    Jeddah, you have become less suspicious to me as you have been more useful in the past couple of days. But can you explain why, on Day 1, you said you were going to vote for a random but then voted for Krakow?
     
  18. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    Less suspicious than both Santiago and Nairobi. He's still a suspect, hence why I mentioned him.

    He also gave me a sneaky vote yesterday without explaining why, which I certainly haven't forgotten about.
     
  19. Tokyo

    Tokyo Academy Graduate

    I don’t see the logic in Santiago being evil.
     
  20. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    I wanted to vote for a quiet player as I strongly believed that both players were good. However as it was a two horse race, it would have been a bit of a cop out.

    On balance, I felt that Helsinki was a little 'more good' than Krakow.
     
  21. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    I'm sorry if it is. I have explained my logic so I am accountable. A lack of information only helps evil.

    If everybody gave such a detailed explanation for their vote, the game would be a lot easier for team good.
     
  22. Oslo

    Oslo Academy Graduate

    Why would you want Seer to view Venice again , I withdraw my above apology .
     
  23. Tokyo

    Tokyo Academy Graduate

    Right, I’ve has a look through again. I’m going for Jeddah. His logic naming Santiago seems like a misdirection and it seems to have had the desired effect. If he’s not a wolf he’s surely the traitor.
     
  24. Jeddah

    Jeddah Academy Graduate

    @The Globe Any chance you could list all votes in order as well as separating them into who each player has voted for? Don't worry if it would take too much time, but would be useful to see.
     
  25. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    Who voted Istanbul and why? Can't see.
     
  26. Elche

    Elche Academy Graduate

    Thought the initial evidence was weak but would like to hear from Santiago about the logic behind asking Venice to be viewed tomorrow.
     
  27. The Globe

    The Globe Academy Graduate

    This is the best I can do so far - in fairness that info isn't usually available on the poll anyway.

    Jeddah: Santiago, Tokyo
    Istanbul: Nairobi*
    Nairobi: Istanbul, Prague
    Santiago: Quito, Oslo, Venice, Jeddah

    The votes for each player are listed chronologically, eg Santiago voted for Jeddah before Tokyo.

    Currently one unaccounted vote for Istanbul - can someone clarify?

    Looks like I might need to send a few chasers out so want to know who needs a reminder.
     
    Jeddah likes this.
  28. Athens

    Athens Academy Graduate

    I'm going to vote for Istanbul to make it 4 each between him and Santiago.

    I just don't have the feeling that it is Santiago he was a bit too vocal at points.
     
  29. Elche

    Elche Academy Graduate

    It's very close at the moment, would be handy if the person who voted for Istanbul without declaring it could do so.
     
  30. Denver

    Denver Academy Graduate

    Jeddah is either a confident player for team good or he is a traitor - I just can’t decide which. This is where having anonymous accounts makes for a good game as I would have a better idea if he/she was playing “against type” if I knew their identity. Jeddah is definitely leading the charge against Santiago. But is this for genuine reasons or has he picked someone who voted for Krakow on Day 1 and made them a scapegoat for the real wolf?
    I am going to vote for Santiago for the following reasons:
    - voted for Krakow on Day 1
    - questioned Oslo after it appeared pretty obvious he had revealed himself as a Mason
    - random comment pointing the finger at Venice, when he has already been confirmed as good

    I also think Nairobi has been playing a strange game and am still suspicious of Athens.
     
  31. Tokyo

    Tokyo Academy Graduate

    Will be a shame if that isn’t unravelled. Not your fault of course. Maybe move the thread to a mod area at 6 for a minute and look at the voting there? Or is gone forever now you’ve edited it not to show?
     
  32. Elche

    Elche Academy Graduate

    Athens going for Istanbul. Historical animosity played out in Werewolf...
     
    Athens and wfcmoog like this.
  33. Santiago

    Santiago Academy Graduate

    Vote for me. Quite honestly, it'll expose at least one as evil.
     
  34. Istanbul

    Istanbul Academy Graduate

    Why would that make me less likely to be the wolf. That doesnt make sense.
     
  35. The Globe

    The Globe Academy Graduate

    Sadly gone - makes sense as having people vote on a private poll and then making it public would be a little nasty elsewhere.

    We will be able to work it out though.

    So far I have:

    Jeddah: Santiago, Tokyo
    Istanbul: Nairobi*
    Nairobi: Istanbul, Prague
    Santiago: Quito, Oslo, Venice, Jeddah

    1 unaccounted vote for Santiago
    1 unaccounted vote for Istanbul

    Athens has said they are voting for Istanbul but no vote seemingly placed? Unless they were slow to post their comment and they are the unaccounted vote for Istanbul.

    Awaiting votes/clarification for:

    @Elche
    @Krakow
    @Moscow
     
    Tokyo likes this.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page