I've been on NW Orn's case since Day 3, I didn't vote for him on Day 5 because I wanted to bring my theory out in the open; had steve harrow turned out good, it would have implicated hornetgags, after he was found evil it meant NW Orn is likely to be evil. The thing is I can't discount Message 1 today being the seer, if so you are up for lynching and WaS's role is also unclear. If NW Orn turns out to be good then it will mean that you are evil (that cannot be denied at that juncture) and WaS would almost certainly be the traitor as I have suspected.
PJ these are all very persuasive words but all based on effectively the same message both on Friday and today naming me. I also don't want us to get it wrong and I can't see past the fact you have been named evil in the 1st message today. Getting your vote in early also starts a witch hunt which as we know has been very successful previously.
I don't want us to get it wrong either which is why I've made my argument and put in my vote first. As I said this is the first time I've been 100% certain of someone. If this Seer message didn't reiterate you I wouldn't have dared stick my neck out like this as I wouldn't have been certain we would have been lynching an Evil. As it did I am sure.
It's a tricky one. NW Orn has been in my sights but PJ is looking over confident. Question is can either NW Orn and PJ prove which message is really from the seer?
Woops, after the weekend break Werewolf completely slipped my mind. Looking like it has to be NW Orn.
I need to get some urgent work done. Won't be around til later. Trust you will all make the right choice.
PJ why do you keep saying the messages naming me are from the seer ? Both could be from the wolf and #bingogate is fairly compelling. The fact wolf just brushed it off with the 2nd message today says it all. Fact is you are just as likely to be evil as me - both of us named. I suspect 1 of us will go today and the other tomorrow.
Sorry NW, after PJ had been named as evil why would the wolf push me through as good ? It would have been easier to sit and say nothing and let PJ hang.
Although suspicious of PJ, I can't ignore the fact that I've been on NW Orn's case since Day 3 and my chart more or less implicated him therefore my vote takes NW Orn over threshold In bold because that's a cue for the traitor that it's safe to vote for him now! If NW Orn is GOOD then PJ will be EVIL, absolutely no doubt. Traitor either WaS or BRLR. If NW Orn is EVIL, then WaS won't necessarily be exonerated but less likely to be evil.
Wow. That took off a bit in my absense. Anyway, if NW is a wolfie then the traitor is now irrelevant and we win.
@Otter is there any chance you can put a powerpoint presentation together for tomorrow showing what you have found ?
Yeah it's a scanned copy of the Traitor's confession naming the Wolf. You mean you can't see it? On a serious note, no. Works just fine.
Ok just got back from a meeting and looks like the die has been cast already. Looks like it has to NW Orn tha gets my vote, based on Otter's spreadsheet (now that it's exonnerated me). So if we get the other wolf, is that game over or do we still have to get the traitor?
Narrowing it down to NWOrn or WAS, pretty much guaranteed a win by tomorrow at latest... Fingers crossed HO doesn't activate a full moon or wasn't there talk of the wolf cub option.
Once the final wolf is gone there are no more night kills. We wont lynch anyone else and the traitor can just do one off to them lot up the road.
I bloody hope you aren't relying on me to be evil If NW turns out to be good and i'm then lynched tomorrow then i will take my hat off to team evil
That won't happen. All that remains to be seen is whether NW is a Wolf or Traitor. If it's Traitor the game goes on.
Page 2 still taking an age to load but just gone through most of it. Anyway. One of those messages is from the seer. FACT. One of PJ and NW are evil. FACT! No one seems to have defended NW or tried to sway the voting to help him. If he is the wolf, where is his traitor? Is he the traitor then, or is he good? Is PJ the wolf and Otter the traitor? Otter has single handedly shifted any blame off off PJ. Only thing in PJ's favour in my opinion is his early vote for steve harrow on Friday. So I'm calling NW as traitor rather than wolf in the absense of any other player diving on his sword to save him. Still think a wolf is out there. But an evil is an evil.
So just in case it's not the wolf but is evil - last few votes for NW. Meh! BRLR Gags NW Orn! Otter SLB WAS NW Orn is irrelevent obviously. Otter has led the way. I am good. SLB is good. WAS voted 4th when it could still be swayed. Gags or BRLR remain in the spotlight. 2 of the last 3 to reluctantly vote.
All 3 of us suddenly reappeared once the decision had already been made!!! Neither of you 2 really seemed to believe in your vote looking at your last comments above.
Pretty confident I know the Seer, the Guardian, the Wolf and the Traitor now. If by some miracle NW Orn turns out to be Good, I think I will have to accept it's time to retire from Werewolf with a rather pathetic record of Played 3, Lost 3.
I just returned from a meeting. The die HAD been cast as there were 6 votes already, and based on Otter's spreadsheet, I was going to vote for NW anyway. There was nothing reluctant about it and it smells like you're trying to manufacture something.
We are miles away from losing dude. Only 1 evil kill tonight so still leaves 6 v 2 if NW was good. PJ would go tomorrow if NW is good so even if he is the traitor it would be 5 v 1.
I think NW Orns traitor , must have realised that his death was a fait accompli and decided to stay low in case there was a full moon .
I'll be in I say we just do a usual game here, and think about an anonymous game later. It would be fun to participate in a game before the season starts.
